Spyke
lemmy.world

Honestly? With the benefit of hindsight, I'm actually pleased it wasn't given the chance to become a Dollhouse.

The movie gave closure, and we left the characters in a good place.

Dollhouse gave us 5 seasons of content in one, and ruined itself in season 2, and many other shows have just run until everyone was sick of them, before getting an anticlimactic ending anyway.

8

This right here showy how Lemmy is superiour to reddit. Back there I always opened the comments whenever this topic was posted (so, once a week) and usually had to scroll waaaaaay down to see the correct answer.

Here it's #1. And 2#.

2
lemmy.world

If you like firefly there's another show similar that was also cancelled too soon. Darkmatter. I actually prefer it over firefly tbh.

13

The comment from @resolved3874 just above this implies this would be a pathway to sadness.

2
lemmy.ml

Game of Thrones. Sad we never got to see past season 6...

Serious answer: I just heard The Peripheral got cancelled after Westworld also got cancelled :l

63
lemmy.ml

Re Peripheral …. Seems to be a victim of the strike, according to Wikipedia. Last I heard it was renewed for a season 2. But they canceled it anyway.

14
Aulireply

Shit I liked that show and the story. I guess at this point don't watch any streaming shows. They are getting to have the google effect it's all getting cancled before the story finishes so why start.

14
lemmy.world

Although I would've loved to see them complete the entire story I was still pretty satisfied with how they left it (other than the edits they made for Alex's story).

10

The Expanse could always be picked back up if Amazon would get it’s head out of its ass. It stopped where the books do a time jump forward and the characters are older.

8
Ugurcanreply
lemmy.world

It didn’t got cancelled to be fair. It was a great show that run much longer than it’s viewership can support, and it was announced way earlier that the story will be wrapped by 6th season.

The Expanse universe is not abandoned either. Telltale Games just launched a new Prequel adventure game a few days ago: https://store.epicgames.com/tr/p/the-expanse-a-telltale-series

1

It did get cancelled. Twice. The show ended roughly where the 6th book ended and was intended to complete the last 3 books, but because it was cancelled, we didn't get to see how they would have handled those books without the time jump.

1

I think the most we might get is a movie. But it would be wild if in ten years or so they actually got the cast back and continued the story like in the books

1
feddit.uk

The Walking Dead.

Should have been cancelled like 9 seasons earlier.

52
lemmy.ca

Took me a few seasons to figure out that every season was the same. "I think we've found a place to settle down, but there might be a problem...".

18
lemm.ee

Yeah but for the first few seasons the problems were new and interesting at least.

7

First season was directed by Frank Darabont who is awesome at making great movies from written works of art. Then AMCunts saw this and fired him after awesome season one and replaced him with Glen Mazzara who never made anything worthy of note. They also doubled the number of episodes for same content and requested that more episodes are shot indoors to make everything earn more money. And it fucking worked.

2
Derpgonreply
programming.dev

I stopped watching when they introduced horrible CGI and fake gun effects (no knock back, no shell ejection, no slide movement).

I'd argue the first few seasons - apart from the horrible acting from time to time, and prolonged passages just to stretch time, and filler episodes, and dumb people, and...

Yeah, it was shitty from the beginning.

13
Jivebunnyreply
lemmy.world

That and the stupid Hyundai always looking like it just rolled out of the shop.

8
Jivebunnyreply
lemmy.world

Yeah, but not quite. I'd never buy one because of this though.

Fun fact: I'm an online marketeer.

4
Blackmistreply
feddit.uk

I was with them up to the end of the second season with the farm.

After that they fell into the cycle of characters having to be excessively stupid to inject drama.

I stopped watching at the point where they pretended Glenn was dead, but he was actually hiding under the bin. Not because it was a cheap trick, but mostly because that was the point where I realised I no longer cared who was alive and dead.

6

I stopped watching when Glenn finally died. Mainly due to the fact that I found out through social media because I missed the first episode of that season when they revealed who got beat with Negan's bat, and everyone on social media ruined the reveal.

He was my favorite character, and I know in the comics he dies much earlier than in the show, but I lost interest after that.

3

Yeah, that was almost the breaking point for me aswell. And IIRC it was a last episode of a season aswell. Fuck that cliffhanger.

3

On the other hand, I would have been happy if Z-Nation had gone on as long as The Walking Dead.

3

I've got two:

Stargate: Universe. I never got into Stargate before, and I really liked what was going on with Universe. Longtime fans didn't. Though, after going back and getting into SG-1 and Atlantis, I very much understand why they hated Universe. The original shit is so much more fun, where Universe was overly serious. I still like the concept, but I think it would have been way better with the campyness of the original shows.

The second is Limitless. It was really fucking good. It was constantly pulling me in. And they cancelled it because too many people found it to be "unrealistic." I'm sorry the show about a neutropic drug that makes you into a super genius isn't real enough for you.

45

Came here specifically to mention Stargate: Universe. It was so good until it got cancelled.

"That is one sweet potato" is still an inside joke I share with a couple of folks.

13

Yep. Was gonna post SGU if it wasn’t already here! It was an interesting show with a good cast.

It could still be rebooted since there were a ton of people on the ship and all of them were in stasis when the show ended.

Another property Amazon is sitting on.

6

SGU was a soap opera in space. So much drama between the characters instead of an outside force much of the time. SG1 was mostly focused on the SG team working together against something external like the goa'uld. Very rarely was there anything other than comradary or in jack and sam's case, romantic feelings and/or sexual tension. The chemistry between the main cast was great. SGA had some degree of intracast member tension but by and large they still worked together well. SGU had a lot of mistrust between Rush and everyone else and for good reason. He was an arrogant dick that put his own interests above others a lot of the time. Keeping secrets from them and generally being unlikable. Eli's arc was just sad. He was away from his mother who later became ill, watched the woman he had a crush on choose someone else and had to personally sever the connection between him and his new romantic interest to save Rush then if that wasnt bad enough, we dont know what happens to him after the finale. SGU might have been ok and I stress ok but not on par with SG1 or SGA if it was a completely separate franchise but alas, it was part of the same franchise and there was no justifying that it held its own against the others.

4

There it is. Didn't think I would find it.

It was amazing. Something completely different and much darker. Still sad it got cancelled :/

2

I finished season two after they canceled it thankfully. I’m glad I didn’t wait in anticipation for it.

Such a cool idea.

2

I dropped off of Limitless HARD after the "smell o vision" episode. I understand it's just entertainment and none of it is real...

But that was too much of a leap to make in terms of suspension of disbelief. I watched Stargate Atlantis, really liked a lot of the show.

1
lemm.ee

Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Star Trek: Enterprise

Freaks & Geeks

Sense8

38

It was cancelled right as it found it's footing. It's like the studio forgot that every Trek show takes about 2 seasons to really find itself and that it then takes a few seasons for the people that wrote it off to give it another chance.

2
lorezreply

Oh, Terminator was so good. Lena Headey was great as Sarah Connor.

5
lemmy.world

My Name is Earl. One of my all time favorites and it was surprise cancelled on a cliffhanger.

32

I am rewatching My Name is Earl at the moment. It is still great in my opinion.

8

If you want closure, here's what was planned for the ending:

Garcia said the finale would begin with Earl getting stuck on a really hard list item, frustrated that he would never finish crossing everything off his list. "Somebody shows up at our motel door," added Suplee recently, "finds us at the bar, and starts to make amends to Earl for something." Earl would then question where the man got such an idea and "goes back and finds all these people who have lists, who are out there trying to do good, and it all comes back to him. He was the beginning of this." Garcia concluded, "Earl eventually realizes that his list started a chain reaction of people with lists and that he’s finally put more good into the world than bad. So at that point he was going to tear up his list and go live his life. Walk into the sunset a free man. With good karma.

4

I don't think The Orville was officially cancelled but there doesn't seem to be any plans for more as far as I know. The last season was great and set up more potential storylines.

30
lemmy.ml

Dirk Gently’s :( fuck you Netflix.

Seriously, cancelling the show WHEN THEY FUCKING OPEN THE HOLISTIC DETECTIVE AGENCY?? My boy Elijah Wood was soo good on this!!! :((

30
Pyrreply
lemmy.ca

I don't understand why Netflix doesn't just make movies instead of TV shows.

Or make short series instead of multi-season.

They are good at making great first season TV but then if it doesn't get their magic number they cancel it and leave their customers hanging.

Just make the one season as an open and closed thing and call it that so no one gets their expectations up.

If it becomes some awesome hit thing, make an actual series as an offshoot / spinoff type thing.

8
lemm.ee

Netflix only cares about new subs. New IPs drive new subs. New seasons of old IPs are money spent on people who are already customers. They make one season of a show you've been waiting for, you sign up, you watch that season, they cancel the show, statistically speaking you probably don't cancel your subscription and then they redirect that money to running the same game on someone else.

9
lemmy.world

This is peak capitalism. Taking your money, not caring about providing you with the service you paid for, and expecting you to bend over and take it.

2

I really don’t understand their business model tbh.

It seems like it’s just “burn as much money as fast as possible”.

6
novibereply
lemmy.ml

Literally one of favourite TV shows ever, and just two seasons*. So many good feelings and great characters. Awesome actors and some of Douglas Adams’s best books ever?

Netflix fucking sucks man.

edit: corrected by peep

2
lemmy.world

You think Netflix fucked over that Dirk Gently?

ITV made a Dirk Gently show that was FOUR EPISODES LONG and it was better than the other show.

2
novibereply
lemmy.ml

Gotta admit I didn’t watch that… I found out about it after I finished the Netflix show, and that it was cancelled. So I felt salty. Maybe I should watch it…

2

It's much closer to the books. It deserved at least a British season of six episodes.

I also like Stephen Mangan's Dirk more than Samuel Barnett's Dirk, but then I'd watch Stephen Mangan read a newspaper.

1
lemmy.world

Rome on HBO was a solid show covering an exciting time in Roman history. Sucks that they only had 2 seasons.

28
SeaJreply

It was too expensive to rebuild the set after the fire. I loved that show.

2

Number one show I wish wasn't cancelled was Firefly, definitely. And more recently, 1899.

24
edricreply
lemm.ee

Oh damn I already forgot about Mindhunter. Definitely needs to come back.

4
lorezreply
lemm.ee

I need more Anna Torv in my life.

2

I just finished watching Mindhunter, I want more. I need more.

2

I've heard the rumor of it taking a ridiculously long break, 10-20 years, before it will continue. Fincher wants to jump the storyline ahead from the 70's to the 90's and have the actors looks age appropriate. Who knows it'll that's really true, or anyone involved will still retain interest. But, if Twin Peaks can pull it off...

2
lemmy.world

Stargate universe ended on a cliffhanger, stargate atlantis ended without dealing with the wraith threat or the evil asgard etc. Star trek enterprise's cancellation resulted in one of the worst most hated last episodes in scifi. Quantum leap ended without ever resolving the main plot. Inside job like most of netflix's decent shows, got killed off for stupid reasons.

23

Farscape is always my answer to these questions. I enjoyed Peacekeeper Wars, but it definitely felt rushed. Had it been a full season, it would have been frelling amazing.

11

Carnivale was so good. I don't remember anything about it other than it being good at this point and I'm not going to ruin it by watching it again.

6

It's worth a watch anyway if you don't mind it ending on an insane cliffhanger lmao. Real shame, one of the most creative and interesting sci fi shows out there.

13

Man Raised by Wolves first season was amazing. But the final season that came out was pretty weird, and the production quality really went down. Like they killed the show before it ended.

But the fucking mysteries and plots for this show were some of the best ever. Pretty sad it ended without any revelation p much.

7
lemm.ee

Limitless.

The movie was pretty superfluously a power fantasy, but the show had actual likeable characters, and long-term intrigue. As far as cop procedurals go, it was way up there.

19

This is an older one, but The Critic. It was on two different networks and lasted only one season on each network. It was a funny show, but the inconsistent schedule killed it way too early.

18
sh.itjust.works

“Happy”, I think a lot of people overlooked it because Christopher Meloni having a cartoon unicorn as a companion seemed cheesy, but the show wasn’t afraid to dive into truly horrific plot lines.

The less-grounded corner of my brain thinks the show was cancelled because it was openly talking about skeletons in the closets of network executives.

17

I totally get why it was not easy to promote, but damn it was good shit.

2
lemmy.zip

Star Trek: enterprise. Probably not the best Trek show but it got dropped right when it had found its stride. Also I enjoyed the temporal war arc, which most trek fans seemed to hate. Would have loved to see the stuff they later revealed in interviews that was planned, like archer himself becoming the suliban leader from the future.

16
xkforcereply
lemmy.world

Arguably Enterprise should have ended before certain things happened in the last episode that fans HATED. Or reboot the friggen series and hand wave it away as part of the time cold war.

4

That episode was so stupid. Even the producers agreed it sucked and that fans should consider the second to last episode the season finale instead.

6

Pushing Daisies really deserved another few seasons, but the (previous) writer's strike left it with a really abrupt and unsatisfying end. There wasn't any other show quite like it.

And of course, the perennial winner of such threads, Firefly. At least that got a movie though.

16
feddit.de

1899

It's a mystery show made by the same people that made Dark and I was so down for it. Then Netflix cancelled it after season 1

15

I didn't start watching it because I was afraid of Netflix cancelling it.

After Netflix cancelled it, I cancelled my subscription.

5

The cliffhanger at the end deserved a second season. Dark was amazing, I think 1899 was going to be as well

1

What makes me really mad is how quickly they canceled it after it aired. Like what the hell man.

0
Björnreply
swg-empire.de

I actually liked that the show got a proper ending. This post shows that there are too many series that just pucker out without getting any plotlines resolved. Fringe had coherent seasons that all did something different instead of staying with a monster of the week formula.

5

Firefly Rome (the last season got cut, and 3&4 got smashed into one season) Sense8 (though the wrap up movie was great) Gargoyles

14

Music videos on MTV Science shows on discovery channel History shows on the history channel Well-produced soft porn on Cinemax Comedy shows with actual writers and actors News shows with actual journalism

14

I forgot how that show ended and convinced my SO to watch it. Imagine my absolute HORROR when that time came around and I realized what I had a just done to her. She was devastated.

5

At least Nickelodeon didn't run it into the ground like they did with Rugrats and SpongeBob or cancel it after one season like Invader Zim.

6
DerpyPointreply
lemmy.world

I took part in the campaign to save it 😭 really want to know what the final three seasons could've been like

4

I really enjoyed Travelers, although I'm glad they were able to end it as they did.

6

After finishing Timeless, I went straight to El Ministerio Del Tiempo and it was everything I wanted Timeless to be for 4 more seasons.

3

Dead like me was just starting to get interesting, when they canceled it and spat out a movie that didn't even try to wrap things up

12
lemmy.world

I will agree only as far as it could be worse.

Kidding aside, it's just not my type of comedy - neither are The Office or Seinfeld if you'd like to use this fact to gauge my taste - but I can't deny the wide appeal of any of these shows.

0
Squizzyreply
lemmy.world

Oh yeah nothing is for everyone, but the anti friends movement is really annoying. Like it is a product of it's time in terms of format and content. It's unlikely to resonate with people born after it ended.

1

Yeah - it's like Labyrinth or the Goonies. If you didn't watch them during their heyday (or grow up with them), they're just weird and annoying. But for a huge audience they're a comfort-watch.

1
lemmy.world

Netflix really screwed with it by renewing it for a second season just to reneg on that renewal a couple of months later. I'm still bitter about that.

4

Meanwhile, they also renewed multiple lazy, creatively dead shows, like Big Mouth. "We've never cancelled a successful show".

2
lemmy.sdf.org

Constantine. It had it's problems, like many Arrowverse shows at the time, but Matt Ryan was a fantastic John Constantine and I thought the show had a lot of untapped potential.

11

The arrow started out so good and then got so awful I couldn't finish it

2

he has a fantastic run on Legends of Tomorrow, never seen the Constantine show as its not on any streaming I’m aware of so not sure how different the character is, but I imagine he plays it similarly. Legends itself is probably the best arrowverse show, after they get past the first season and stop taking it seriously.

1
lemmy.world

The Dark Crystal. That first series was a great build up and the preview at the end of it for the next looked awesome.

11

Sarah Connor Chronicals. Was pretty good throughout but then ramped up to off the walls amazing, just in time to be cancelled on a cliffhanger

11
lemm.ee

Not exactly a cancelation, but Star Trek TNG. All of the characters were far more developed than TOS's, which is why they didn't work as well in movies. Better for them to have their own episodes than to unsuccessfully have them share a movie. Any of them could have been just as good, if not better, as multi-part episodes.

11
lemmy.world

I think TNG ended at just the right time. Cracks were showing during the final season with the writers running out of ideas.

13

People need to remember- by then we'd had the 'Beverly fucks a ghost candle' episode. I think they were done.

2

I'd say that's mainly a consequence of needing to produce so many episodes per season, not an indication that there were no stories left for the characters.

1

Sarah Connor Chronicles. They'd just jumped into serious weirdness and the world building lore had developed in a really interesting way.

10
Björnreply
swg-empire.de

Never watched the second season because I knew there wasn't coming anything else.

1

@Cheems

The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance. I was in awe with this show. Had waited years for it and was not disappointed! I loved the story and the set pieces were absolutely gorgeous. You could tell a lot of love and care was put into it. I was hoping they’d go all the way with this show and that it would end naturally as a full prequel story to The Dark Crystal.

But no. Netflix pulled the plug on Age of Resistance after the first season because it was too expensive. It still stings to this day.

10

Reaper. It was a fun show with a great premise. Basically, a couple sells their sons soul to the devil before he is born. Then on his 21st birthday the devil arrives and informs him he is going to be a bounty hunter for hell. Also, Ray Wise played an awesome devil.

10

Final Space deserves to be mentioned here. I know there's a wrap up graphic novel slated and I'm super excited to see where Olan goes with Godspeed. But having the whole ip basically wiped off the face of the earth as a tax write off has to be one of the most messed up ways to cancel a show...

10

Travellers. Magicians. If I had to choose only one, it would be Magicians, that show really needed one last season.

9
Crashumbcreply
lemmy.world

I've tried Magicians several times. I can't get past the whining little lead actor. I just can't stand his character.

1

Yeah, Quentin is a bit punchable in the first episodes, but I really liked him as a character starting somewhere in the 1st season. Who I couldn't stand was Penny.

3

I'm glad to see Carnivàle has already been mentioned. If I could choose only one, that is it. There are many others that have been mentioned that are also on my list though. About the only shows I can think of that I haven't seen mentioned but would also add are Penny Dreadful and Jupiter's Legacy.

8

Ha! Simpsons is the reason I know this, same as Barney's (Gumble)

1

Deadwood. It is still a classic top 5 HBO show, but unfortunately with so much wasted potential and unexplored storylines. I do rewatch it from time to time, but the knowledge of what could have been is kinda detracting from my full enjoyment of it.

Boardwalk Empire. It got more seasons than Deadwood at least, and also had a final episode which kinda wrapped things up, but it was so rushed and contrary to the general pace of the show that it is very jarring to watch.

7

I rewatch Key & Peele regularly, it's amazing. So well done

5

Inside Job.

I didn't really watch shows on Netflix and I couldn't care less about people complaining about their shows being cancelled left and right. But Inside Job was recommended by my friend and I loved it. After finding out it was cancelled after 2 seasons, I finally understood the pain these people were feeling all along...

7

This appeals to Hongkongers only, but I miss 頭條新聞 (News Headlines) (I made up this translation)

Despite its name, this was a sarcastic show aired on RTHK, an official government channel. It talks about a lot of events, poor decisions and wrong-doings of the government in a funny way. Unfortunately it was shut down in 2020, by the government.

Our democracy and freedom have been declining since then.

Here's a playlist of them archived

7
feddit.de

Legends of Tomorrow

I mean, come on, we just got Donald Faison as Booster Gold in the final episode of season 7 and then they go and cancel it

6
Perfidereply
reddthat.com

Exactly what I was gonna say. The show was just starting to get good again after a couple mediocre seasons, and then they fucking cancel it on a cliffhanger?

3

I wouldn't say mediocre, but 7 was certainly the best one since 3 and very unique

0

That show should have been cancelled when they turned it into a nonsense comedy that was like a low budget, unfunny Rick & Morty. An unpopular opinion, I know, but it started off with such potential and turned into a joke.

-1

Really? I enjoyed that show for a while but when a member of his family was kidnapped for the third time I just entirely gave up on it

4

still salty about Glow and Legends of Tomorrow. Both were set up for, and could’ve been finished with, a final season.

6

The F Word. It showed a different side of Ramsay and it was more about food than his other ones.

5

American Gods literally waited until right before the last episode to cancel it

5

All good suggestions in this thread, but I'm going to throw it back to Sports Night. It had an incredible cast, great writing, and tons of potential.

5

Ended on such a strong note, always broke my heart it didn’t get picked up, but it introduced me to the work of Jonathan Tucker.

1

Terra Nova was awesome... at least... I thought so.

:(

4
lemmy.world

My constant responses to this question is obviously Flash Forward.

Boy was that a great show, with an amazing premise. I think about this show to this day.

3
lemmy.world

I learned today that there are 2 shows called Flash Forward, but if you are talking about the one from 1995 with Jewel Staite then I agree. Also Space Cases.

2

A couple that I have not seen:

  • Happy Endings
  • Newsroom
3
lemmy.ml

Terriers and Rubicon are my go-to answers for this. I do wonder how they hold up though, it's been a while.

3

Rubicon was an interesting show. Could probably be rebooted. Especially if they could talk the actor who played the main character into making mysterious cameo appearances like he’s been in hiding or something.

2

Stargate Universe. It was Stargate meets Battlestar Galactica and I loved it. It wasn't without its issues, but I felt it was really finding it's feet. Then it ends on a cliffhanger after 2 seasons

3

The Bastard Son & The Devil Himself. Thought it was very interesting, I loved the magic system and the characters were well developed. It was a really fun journey and the production was such an interesting vibe.

3

The Get Down was such a good show with a fun aesthetic. It was about the birth of hip hop but talked a lot about the politics and culture at the time. It lasted 2 seasons on Netflix and somewhat on a cliffhanger for a few characters, and I wish they got another season or two to fully wrap it up.

3

Crusade. The story was just starting to get interesting but JMS had used all of his pull just getting the fifth season of B5 on the air. I'm cautiously optimistic about the animated series that was hinted at by The Road Home but I'm also not holding my breath.

3

If I had to pick one, I'd be very torn between Flash Forward, Odyssey 5 and Terminator TSCC. Probably the first one.

3

Bonding. First season was ridiculous wrt consent in bdsm but the whole shit was giving hilarious. S2 they tried fixing the consent thing and seemingly forgot to be as funny.

2

Drive, starring Nathan Fillion and Emma Stone. Didn't even last a season.

2

Take my love

Take my land

Take me where I cannot stand

I don't care 'cause I'm still free

You can't take the sky from me

2

MODOK was stupid fun and had robot chicken vibes at times. Sad it left off the way it did.

1

Flash Forward I think the problem was filler episodes. Imagine it being launched today. Only 8-10 great episodes.

1

What about Brian. Mostly because I think it was the first show that I ever got into that was cancelled without resolving the story. Didn't know that was a thing that could happen.

1

It voluntarily ended but one more season of Seinfeld. They said the show was getting too ridiculous but one more season of ridiculous would've been nice.

1

Revolution

Ended right before it was going to start getting crazy.

1

I don't know the scoop on whether or not it's actually cancelled or if season 6 is in Max/Cartoon Network limbo or what is even going on with it, but I'm saying Summer Camp Island.

1

I am not okay with this - I was so excited when I watched that seried but then it was announced that it would be cancelled. The only season had a plot twist at the end that the comic didn't have and I was really excited to see where it goes. But Netflix couldn't let that happen.

0

Sit down, and shut up. I thought it was hilarious, like Rick and Morty, just without aliens

-1