Indiana judge rules tacos, burritos are sandwiches
https://www.wishtv.com/news/indiana-news/indiana-judge-rules-tacos-burritos-are-sandwiches/Open linkView original on lemmy.world424
Comments141
https://www.wishtv.com/news/indiana-news/indiana-judge-rules-tacos-burritos-are-sandwiches/Open linkView original on lemmy.world
Things like this seem silly but there's likely laws or protection that use sandwiches in their wording.
Defining things you want them to apply to as sandwiches is easier than changing the law.
Makes more sense than the time Indiana tried to define pi as 3.2. The only reason it didn't was because a professor from Purdue was in Indianapolis on unrelated business and convinced Indiana's senate to table the bill.
Of course, we know today that such a thing couldn't happen since Indiana's legislature would laugh at the woke lib and pass it just to trigger him.
Well two decimal places invokes the devil, as does rounding correctly.
"sig what now? Sounds like the trans liberal leftist nazi woke agenda to me"
That is why in California, bees are fish
Someone is going to find stuff like this in the future and think we're dumb as fuck. They'd be right, but not because of this.
also, hippos and capybara are fish.
But fish don’t exist.
But why do they even have laws about sandwiches in the first place?
Read the article. It's a zoning issue.
I'm sorry sir, this is a sandwich only zone. You and your parfait need to leave immediately.
we're just loading the parfait i swear
Something existing does not answer the question about WHY it exists.
That isn't a law or zoning then, just some contract dispute.
They are trying to exclude traditional fast food like McD's,Wendy's, etc.
WHY
Cuz fuck mcds you dense prick
But not fuck Subway?
K
Could be food safety, taxes, production rules or any number of things.
The article does not mention any sandwich specific laws, just contract stuff about what kind of restaurant can be in a strip mall.
Damn straight, if you ordered a sandwich in a restaurant and they brought you a burrito or taco.. you'd be really confused and a bit annoyed that you didn't get what you asked for.
This makes some sense as all foods are salads; sandwiches are untossed salads, tacos are untossed taco salads.
https://saladtheory.github.io/
That's bad taxonomy, because then what's a taco salad? It's an untossed taco salad salad. But we still don't know what taco means. So it's becomes an untossed untossed taco salad salad salad. Which becomes an untossed untossed untossed taco salad salad salad salad. We never learn what a taco actually is.
It's like the G in GNU.
Exactly! I had to look it up, but yes, it is.
I say there are four categories:
Does this mean lasagna is a sandwich?
Correct
This falls into a common trap. Because we cannot succinctly define a salad in one sentence we decide that it cannot be defined at all. This argument effectively reducto ad absurdums itself by coming to the conclusion that all foods are salad.
If we start from a position where we discount nothing from being a salad, and we have only salads (and soup, seemingly) to base our analysis on, how can we ever identify the boundaries of salad? The whole argument is based on the flawed premise that anything could be a salad.
I realise that I am thinking too hard about this.
Then what’s a wedge salad? “Ingredients “?
Finally, some legislation from the middle of the country that makes sense.
But also:
That's what a Torta is!
Both can be true.
So is a taco a torta?
Sandwich is the more generic word. So a torta is a sandwich, and so is a taco, but a torta is not a taco, and a taco is not a torta. Both of them are specific types of sandwich.
Just like a square is a rectangle, but a rectangle is not a square.
Is a poor boy a philly cheese steak?
Preposterous. Burritos are calzone.
By that logic, cupcakes can be multiple things depending on how you eat them.
If the cupcake is whole and frosted on top like how they’re normally served, you have toast. But if you rip off the bottom and turn it upside down and place it on the top, it is a sandwich. If you inject the frosting into the middle with a piping bag like an unemployed donut maker, it becomes a calzone.
What I’m saying is cupcakes are valid options for all meals of the day.
Exactly! Q.E.D.!
Reminder that legality is not based on morality.
Or common sense.
I TOLD YOU! I TOLD YOU ALL!!! EVERYONE LAUGHED WHEN I SAID A HOT DOG ON A BUN IS A SANDWICH WELL WHO'S LAUGHING NOW??
I would have argued with you before today, because a hot dog is clearly a taco. But I guess if tacos are sandwiches, then by the transitive property, it is also a sandwich.
-Unrest in the Middle East as Israel and Palestine refuse to reconcile
-2 years on, the war in Ukraine has no end in sight
-The climate crisis keeps getting worse
-America debates how to categorize Mexican food
Turns out the rest of the world doesn't stop just because some fucked up shit is happening.
I am sure this judge has all the say in those situations.
I mean, this is more about a local business being locked out from developing a new location in an area because that are has specific rules about what can be opened in that area (because Political Money) because for some reason only ships that sell sandwiches are allowed to open up in that region.
We think it's because Panera or another major shop being buddy buddy with legislators
You are surprised? We argued over tomatoes being a fruit or vegetable and if they are a vegetable, then ketchup must count as a serving of vegetable. So the argument over tacos and burritos being a sandwich only surprises me in that fact it took so long to argue about it in court.
Also I jerked off this morning. Not nearly so important as war, but definitely nicer.
Good enough for New York, good enough for Indiana
https://www.vox.com/2014/7/22/5877325/new-york-law-sandwich-burrito-tax
Okay, who will go to court for the cereal soup question next?
First, you need to find a place where soup restaurants have some special privileges compared to normal businesses. Then, just start a soup restaurant there and serve cereal and milk instead.
If you can’t find such a place, then maybe you can ask your local politicians to pass a bill like that. Would be nice if soup restaurants had to pay only half the amount of taxes compared to everyone else. Would be good for the owners, and fun for everyone else to see where the resulting legal battles go. Suddenly, you would find lots of companies selling just about anything and everything as soup and claiming they don’t have to pay the usual taxes.
https://cuberule.com/
Incorrect.
I prefer my sushi infinite-sided, thank you very much.
a wrap has 3 sides. The two ends, and the rest.
So..... a hot dog is a taco?
Yes, by definition
Burritos have an inside and an outside, therefore sandwich.
Sandwich: 🥪 (two disconnected slices of bread cut from a larger loaf 🍞)
Wrap: 🌯 (one continuous flat bread)
Burger: 🍔 (a halved bun, therefore it's also Chicken Burger, not Chicken Sandwich)
Taco (🌮) feels like belonging broadly in the wrap category being based on flat bread.
I'm sending the cops over to your house right now.
It's worse then that. This all because people didn't want Mexican restaurant in a strip mall what the fuck is wrong with these people?
Is a sub/hoagie a sandwich? Bread is usually connected.
Oh God, why did I get involved
If it is, then a hotdog is a sandwich and that's just nonsense.
No kidding... a hotdog is clearly a taco.
It's not two slices of bread from a bigger loaf, so no.
those poor sandwich shop owners are all going to go out of business when they hear the news
Yeah, with that hard competition by taco stands...
Hmm, what of rolls? Ciabatta, Kaiser rolls? Even croissants? By this definition it seems they'd be burgers, since rolls are cut in half. But then my roast beef sandwich is a lying, cold, sad burger
You have weird Ciabattas if you think that Ciabatta is a kind of bun and not a bigger loaf. Croissants are pastry. And yes, burgers made with Kaiser rolls are totally burgers:
But tacos traditionally are more like wraps by your definition, with the exception being hard/crunchy tacos which are on what i would technically call a chip, this making crunchy tacos just portable nachos
Additionally walking tacos are supported by a chip bag, making them neither a taco nor nachos.
Maybe I'm doing injustice here but I've always thought of soft tacos as a lazy wrap.
from a topological perspective, wraps and tacos are two different beasts.
in a wrap, the bread completely surrounds (and encloses) the other ingredients, so theres a 2-dimensional hole involved (which basically means the inside is hollow).
in a taco, no such wholes are present.
you can also distinguish sandwiches from tacos and wraps (since sandwiches involve two pieces of bread, like you said). but unfortunately, you can’t topologically distinguish a burger from a sandwich
Hamburgers are a specific style of sandwiches whose name is derived from Hamburg, Germany.
Chicken sandwiches are not hamburgers.
A chicken sandwich is a sandwich when the chicken meat is between two slices of bread cut from a bigger loaf. It's a chicken burger when it's between two halves of a bun.
And as you said, hamburger derives from the German city of Hamburg, so Germans, not Americans, have the authority here.🤪
This tuling was passed due to a contract obligation to open a sandwich store. These cases are ueually related to regulations. Kind of like when an Irish court ruled that Subway subs are cakes, so higher VAT and sugar tax would apply to them. (In all fairness, the sugar content in the Subway "bread" is several times higher than the max allowed for bread.)
On whose authority??
That Judge's apparently.
We already have the Cube Rule of Food Identification Unifying Theory. Tacos are Tacos. Burritos are Wraps. These guys need to get with the program. We base our food taxonomy on the specific arrangement of carbohydrates like civilized people.
Appeal that shit immediately. Start a Gofundme. This injustice cannot stand.
Indiana is fuckin stupid
But is a quesadilla a sandwich?
I have to disagree here. It is unleavened bread.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unleavened_bread
I'm surprised Merriam-Webster doesn't know that.
Idk man I consider wraps as sandwiches
True. Arabic wraps (chicken shawarma for example) are considered sandwiches.
HOT TACO SANDWICHES!
Most participants in this debate are far too preoccupied with the shape or structure of the sandwich, to the point of neglecting what a sandwich is all about. It's simple. A sandwich is when you use bread as a handheld base for prepared foods that would otherwise be too messy to eat with your fingers. A tortilla is a flat bread, ergo handheld burritos and soft tacos are sandwiches.
"Then why isn't pizza an open-faced sandwich?" Because pizza has a crust, not bread. When you take raw dough and bake it along with its toppings or fillings, it may be a pie or a pastry or a pizza or a casserole or some other category I don't care to quibble over. It's not a sandwich.
Obviously there are many sub-categories of sandwiches. A dish isn't necessarily excluded from being a sandwich just because it's also another type of food.
Is a tortilla bread or is it a very floppy cracker? We may need adjudication.
Crackers are crisp and brittle by definition. "Floppy Cracker" is an oxymoron (and potentially a good name for a garage band?).
I don't see you wearing black robes or holding a gavel.
What about a wizard hat?
I don't know, are we judging whether or tacos belong in Griffindor or Hufflepuff?
Would a tostada then be a floppy cracker fried crisp?
No, crackers are a type of bread. Tostadas are cracker versions of tortillas. Corn tortillas are whole grain flat breads.
Pupusas and tamales are like his pizza example where the masa dough is cooked with its fillings. But those are both types of dumplings, which would make pizza an open-faced dumpling 🤔
Mexican American sandwich please! Yes with Cesar's salad and beans and rice.
He's wrong!
Take it up with the legislature, pal.
Who does a guy need to bribe around here to get something changed?
Finally vindication for what I have argued for years.
Now, if only some brave state will legally define a pizza as a type of sandwich the damn sandwich conservatives can have their comeuppance.
Pizzas are open-faced sandwiches. I learned this in culinary class in high school. Why is it so hard?
Chicago style is a pie.
When does it stop being a sandwich and start being pie? Is a sufficiently cheesy grilled cheese or quesadilla pie also? Your comment has really opened a can of worms for me.
Imo it becomes a pie if the crust is over 2" thick/tall
So is Detroit Style a sandwich or a pie? And is it even a style or a marketing gimmmick?
I think I've even had a few Chicago style pizzas that would count as a soup in a bread bowl.
Is New York style folded a quesadilla?
KANGAROO COURT!
We need to bring in experts on this matter. Someone summon Guy Fieri.
Does anybody know what the orange-ish sauce in the picture is?
When I go to the place this is about, thats just Red Sauce.
It's hot, like fucking real hot. Like make you reconsider your choices if you put it on your taco too liberally, but it's so good.
Aside from the discussion about whether the taco or burrito constitutes a sandwich, I think the judge made the correct ruling. The retail agreement says no “traditional fast food” can set up shop in that mall, and specifically cites drive thrus and outdoor seating as the reasons.
The strip mall owners probably don’t want businesses taking over common sidewalks or creating more traffic than the shared parking lot can handle. So long as they don’t have those, I don’t see any reason a Mexican food place can’t fit entirely into the leased space.
E: also based on their website this place looks bangin
They might be in indiana
I read Indiana Jones. That's all I camr here to say.
Goodbye
Flies away
Burgers are sandwiches.
Hotdogs are tacos.
Burritos are calzones.
Correct. The Cube Rule of Food Identification is used properly here.
How come taco is it's own style but burrito isn't? I'd say calzone is a burrito.
If one is the other, than what's on which side of the equation doesn't really matter. They're still the same thing.
So sure a calzone is also a burrito. No difference really.
hard disagree. hotdogs are made with leavened bread, tortillas are a flatbread.
hotdogs are an open-faced sandwich.
I'm imagining a hot dog balancing on half a bun.
Hot dogs are just very congealed soup with soft croutons on the outside.
Everything is just congealed soup when you really think about it.
It works. my grandpa’s quirky sandwich! Make a kosher hot dog, slice lengthwise, put on a slice of bread, pile high garlic salt and hot sauce, then the second slice. I do think it started off with him trying to make something no one would eat, but my brothers and I jumped on it, especially when it horrified the Moms. He always acted like a little kid with how happy it made him: us kids (even if he was 70+) vs the moms!
Oh I've done something similar! Get some curry ketchup on there and you've got a currywurst sandwich.
That's a sandwich though, the above comment said open face, so it's just a whole hotdog teetering on a cut open half of a hot dog bun.
The top is still open, the bun is split on the bottom.
By that definition, all other sandwiches are open faced unless sealed on every side.
My local grocery carries hot dog shaped pita bread - that’s the only way we eat hot dogs now, fill em up with onions, chili, relish and mustard!
A hot dog is a gyro
Gyros are Greek tacos?
Look up Oki Dog. Definitely a burrito. Then ponder how badly you want one and how direly you'll regret it should you ever eat one.
that's neither a sandwhich nor a burrito. but an abomination.
(Well, okay. technically it's a burrito with a weiner in it. but it's not a hotdog.)(Still an abomination)
I wonder what you would think of the Swedish Tunnbrödrulle...
I’ll try almost any thing once. (There are limits. Fried grubs were like spicy/savory gummy bears. Baby octopus in red curry was amazing. “Live” baby squid was… interesting. Aborted duck egg is a hard nope.)
I suspect it has a lot to do with what else goes in it.
I don't know if I could handle one today but God they were good when I was younger
Do they have an up dog?
What's up dog?
Not much, what's up with you?
Aaaayyyyyyyy
Hotdogs are grinders.
The top level distinction is topology.
Second level could be material categorization.
Legally, at least two of those are sandwiches in the state of Indiana.
this is definitely an indiana activity.
That much i can confirm.
This is just so some NIMBY tools can't ban a burrito place from going into a space that was oddly defined to practically mandate a subway restaurant or other sub shop that isn't explicitly fast food.
RADICAL SANDWICH ANARCHY!!!
TOASTER STRUDEL IS A SANDWICH!!!