Spyke

Replies

Comment on

ruled men make good rules

Ignoring for a moment that apparently women don't exist in that world, even the premise doesn't hold: Bad times don't make hard people, bad times make sick, malnourished, badly educated and/or desperate people, none of which is conductive to making the proposed following of the good times.

If any of that were true, the good times in the so called first world should've made their peoples so soft compared to the hard peoples that should've been created literally everywhere else that the last 300 years of war or so should've ended very differently.

It's a racist propaganda trope that harkens back to ancient Rome where senators decried the "soft" Roman lifestyle compared to the "hard" germanic tribes and has gathered connotations of blood-and-earth ("Blut und Boden", no idea how thats translated) and other unsavory shit in the meantime.

I like to call it the "Fremen Mirage" after the awesome blog collection of a historian I very much like: https://acoup.blog/2020/01/17/collections-the-fremen-mirage-part-i-war-at-the-dawn-of-civilization/

Props to grindr for judo-ing this pile of worms to a place the original poster presumably wouldn't have liked very much

fuck_ai

Comment on

"phd-level reasoning"

Reply in thread

Really looking forward to being the single human thats made responsible because I didn't catch all the bullshit before production.

Just recently we had some google guys at my workplace to hype up the hype some more. One of our leadership (they're honestly great people) asked about the risk of obscuring the learning of our junior developers (by not hiring them), so that in a few years we'd have no seniors to verify the bullshit. The response was unironically that we'd need no seniors in a few years 😄

fuck_ai

Comment on

When Asked to Generate an Alphabet Poster for Preschoolers, the Latest Version of ChatGPT Just Flails Wildly

Reply in thread

No idea why OP did it, but for me it demonstrates that the claims of techbros that these LLMs are working on a reasoning level comparable to PhD, is wildly exaggerated. It puts into question if spending literal trillions of dollars for this crap is a good idea, when 250 billion (inflation adjusted) could build the large hadron collider, or a meager 25 billion a year could prevent world hunger.

Comment on

Over 10,000 Docker Hub images found leaking credentials, auth keys

Read the article so you don't have to:

Unlike the title suggests, the docker images they found won't leak your credentials when you use them, but already contain the credentials of whoever created the image (p.e. through .env files that were accidentally added to the image).

While it contains the valuable reminder to avoid long lived credentials (like API - keys) or use secrets-stores, this "leak" is on the same level as accidentally pushing confidential information to github IMHO.

Fix: have both .gitignore and .dockerignore files and make sure they both contain .env. You use .env and don't hardcode your secrets, right?

fuck_ai

Comment on

"phd-level reasoning"

Reply in thread

The machine thinks that 7 trips are needed to cross the river, because it doesn't understand the question. Readers with actual comprehension understand that only one trip is needed, because the question is not a riddle, even though the it is phrased to resemble one.

fuck_ai

Comment on

"phd-level reasoning"

Reply in thread

I mean, this is just one of half a dozen experiments I conducted (replicating just a few of the thousands that actual scientists do), but the point stands: what PhD (again, that was Sam Qltman'sclaim, not mine) would be thrown off by a web search?

Unless the creators of LLMs admit that their systems won't achieve AGI by just throwing more money at it, shitty claims will prevent the field from actual progress.

fuck_ai

Comment on

"phd-level reasoning"

Reply in thread

But these systems work on interrupting the user's input

I'm not entirely sure what you mean here, maybe because I'm not a native speaker. Would you mind phrasing that differently for me?

That's got nothing to do with "PhD" level thinking, whatever that's supposed to mean.

Oh, we're absolutely in agreement here, and it's not me that made the claim, but what Sam Altman said about the then-upcoming GPT 5 in summer. He claimed that the model would be able to perform reasoning comparable to a PhD - something that clearly isn't happening reliably, and that's what this post bemoans.

It's just fancy autocorrect at this point.

Yes, with an environmental and economic cost that's unprecedented in the history of ... well, ever. And that's what this post bemoans.

Comment on

Sad little butthurt .ml admin strikes again!

Reply in thread

Not sure how to react to your comment, given that I read it through Lemmy. I came here after leaving reddit about a year ago or two, but it seems like we on Lemmy are the bad ones?

I didn't particularly notice it, but have I fallen with a bad crowd, in your opinion? .ml instances and the occasional troll aside, it seems much more constructive and grounded than reddit 😬

Comment on

WhatsApp, Signal, untraceable security risk

Reply in thread

While I appreciate your refusal to spread panic, would you mind explaining what the attack does and why it's a nothingburger, maybe even why it's not practical? Because right now, you assert a lot of things without any explanation.

Not saying you're wrong, but I think it's good practice to not just rely on claims of authority

Comment on

Sad little butthurt .ml admin strikes again!

Reply in thread

Those are good points, thank you very much. I just never connected the dots from Lemmy devs to admins - in my mind they were completely disconnected.

From a cursory check, it seems like piefed is at a good enough place to just switch over - would you say that's a place worth supporting? Or would I just jump from the frying pan into the fire?

Again, I truly appreciate your taking the time to share your experience!

Comment on

What programming language would you recommend for teaching to non-technical people that use a variety of different OSes?

Reply in thread

If it's a nontechnical crowd with no intention of using this knowledge in the workplace for actual programming, I'd agree with the other poster who recommended scratch: it's a visual, object oriented language, so there are hardly chances for typos, it's designed for learning, it runs in the browser. It's a great language for kids and older "first contacts"