Spyke

Replies

Comment on

German court: ChatGPT violated copyright law by ‘learning’ from song lyrics

Reply in thread

All of that is incorrect.

You can check the GEMA fees here: https://www.gema.de/portal/app/tarifrechner/preisrechner - I had it calculate the fees for a 4-hour concert with 100 seats and an entrance fee of 5 Euros, and the total GEMA fee is 31,35 €. If all seats are filled, that is less than 10% of your income. Certainly a lot of money, but a far cry from "all of said fee or even more".

Secondly, if you are not a GEMA member and all the music you play is non-GEMA (and written by yourself), you don't have to pay anything, see here for example: https://www.anwalt.de/rechtstipps/gema (central quote: "Der GEMA-Pflicht unterliegen dabei alle Musikwerke, für die sie die Verwertungsrechte erhalten hat", translation: "GEMA liability applies to all musical works for which it has received exploitation rights.")

I don't like the GEMA either, but let's stay with the verifiable facts, please.

Comment on

English moment

Reply in thread

English is a pretty simple language to learn, but the pronunciation isn't part of that simplicity. It's especially tough to unlearn wrong pronunciations you've cultivated for years. In my case (for instance), sword (which I pronounced like "word") and realm (re-alm).