I am in software and I don't think it's that clear cut tbh. There's definitely a right and wrong way to use AI. I think a lot of companies are moving fast and breaking things right now, but a lot of them are going to find out that the thing they broke is the product and they won't be able to slop their way out of a problem they slopped their way into.

At a micro scale, AI is pretty good at writing workable code quickly. This obviously boosts productivity at the individual level, especially in the short term. At a macro scale, good maintainable software requires higher order thinking that transformer based models simply cannot do. So a lot of the stochastic micro decisions an AI makes lead to technical debt that is not trivial to remove, and can't really be resolved by the AI itself, at least not in a way that won't contribute to the problem.

These issues can be curbed by the programer at the point of origin, before it gets out of hand, but obviously that requires more judicious use which cuts into the productivity gains. Because writing code has never been the hard part of software.

TL;DR: fully embracing the slop machine will eventually poison your product in a way that is not really easily recoverable. It is useful, but not "too good to not use."

The hardware requirements are substantial. If companies or individuals want to run models locally, especially at the speed you'd expect from the big name models, then everyone needs a pretty serious GPU on their work station. That or the company needs to build and maintain a server capable of running whatever loads they expect to see.

None of this is impossible of course. But you pay for the tokens one way or another. Either you pay the upfront cost of the hardware and continuing cost of the electricity to run it, or you pay with the inconvenience of running a model very slowly on lower end hardware, or you pay a subscription for someone else to worry about all that.

This is why local models are still niche. Only hobbyists nerds are willing to go through the trouble of setting up and running a local model. Most companies still are not sure if AI is actually worth it for them. So it's much easier to pay for tokens than the giant upfront cost required to build you own infrastructure.

If the numbers the AI companies are putting up as far as infrastructure cost vs revenue are anything to go by, it probably isn't worth it to most companies.

That's cool but some guy who read a lot of Harry Potter fan fiction about it says we're all gonna die. /s in case it's needed lol.

Also not the person you responded to but in my experience, yes. I don't tell it to "save it in its memory files" because I don't think that's a thing, but including "do not actually edit any files, only propose changes" somewhere in the initial prompt of a conversation has worked well for me.

I think it's kind of ablist to assume a disabled person has nothing of value to offer, like if they can't move a couch then they are excluded. "Moving a couch" could be anything, it could be filing taxes or cooking a meal. Disabled people are good at stuff too. I think it's really weird for you to make this assumption.

I’ll be real - Atlanta, New Orleans, Nashville, Charleston, etc are all flooded with tourists and immigrants. Now this isn’t me being racist, I’m not even from the South- but there’s a huge difference between these cities that LARP as Southern to tourists and cities in the countryside that genuinely don’t have to. It’s a real shame how the culture has changed in the South, and it’s sad that most foreigners don’t realize that. So I don’t blame residents for recognizing that.

Weird how that sounds super racist now huh?

Arnold is 6'2" and was ~250 pounds in his peak body building days. Andre was 7'4" and ~500 pounds. There were lots of huge dudes at the time but Andre really was kind of in a league of his own.

I'm in my early 30's and I remember the opposition to gay marriage when I was a kid in the 2000's, it was strong and very visible. This was in a Southern California beach town, not exactly a bastion of conservatism. Hell, Obama was opposed to gay marriage when he first ran for president. Things changed very quickly as we entered the 2010's.

Not the person you replied to, but the top right frame appears to be a reference to him.

This isn't just a case of some abrasive people involved. The guy who runs the project, DHH, is an open and proud racist. He posts his very straightforward racist beliefs on his blog. He made ruby on rails, and after being rejected from the ruby community he's now trying to insert himself into the Linux/open source community. On top of that, the "distro" is Arch + some dot files. Despite that, he's managed to raise millions of dollars in outside funding, which is insane for open source project. Either his industry connections are willing to look past the racism and hand him a bunch of money anyway, or they actively agree with him and want to build a space for racists in the open source community.

Add in the AI stuff and people have plenty of reason to boycott this project.

This reminds me of a reddit post from a while ago. Dude is going to a university in the US. He's randomly contacted by campus police to let him know that a student has taken out a restraining order on him. He's a graduate student, and the student who took out the restraining order is from one of his classes that's typically for undergrads. Other than sharing that class, he doesn't know the student. Never even spoken to them. He's on a student visa, if he's expelled, he'll likely be deported. He's not allowed to speak to the student and campus police won't even tell him why the restraining order is in place.

After doing some investigation on his own, he finds out the student is dating one of his roommates, who he also doesn't know very well. The roommate is stalking the student, and another roommate is helping the stalker.

The student who took out the restraining order had seen him with the stalker at some point and, because the class they share is typically for undergrads, assumed he only took the class to keep an eye on the student for the stalker.

He was able to go to his graduate advisor about it and luckily it all got cleared up, the student withdrew the restraining order. But his whole academic career was nearly derailed because a random person was able to take out a restraining order on him with zero direct evidence, and there was no established means by which he could defend himself.

Honestly the popular linux distros are pretty polished / user friendly these days. You'll run into little issues, and you need to be at least a little bit curious / tech savvy to figure them out, but it's nothing a little googling can't solve typically.

Man this is like a 4/10 on the scale of "weird shit RFK jr. has done with a dead animal"

My understanding is that the lithium itself isn't the issue, it's that lithium batteries require other rare earths like cobalt where as sodium itself is not only more common than lithium, but it uses more common material like iron or tin in its battery chemistry that are also less problematic.

I draw the line when you start deliberately targeting people to exclude on the basis of their race or culture.

Also, preventing other people from experiencing a culture does not protect it.

The point of this comment was not to draw a comparison between these 4 cities. I just picked 4 well known southern cities.

The standard layout "just works" 99% of the time, the exact same as a console controller layout. All the fancy stuff is there if you want it, but very rarely required.

Many cars have the modem / LTE as a module that can be disabled. On my car, a 2018 Chevy, the LTE antenna plugs into a networking module in the footwell. I bought an antenna cable and dummy load resistor on Amazon for ~$10 and simply unplugged the LTE antenna in the car and plugged in the dummy antenna. That disables all cell network connectivity but doesn't effect things like Bluetooth. It's also easily reversible if someone wanted to do that for some reason.

You can probably Google something like "year make model disable LTE" or "disable telemetry" to get an idea of how hard it would be on your car. Some make it very cheap / easy and some make it very difficult.

You can get them for pretty reasonable prices on eBay. I got mine last year for like $60

I don't think the person you're responding to is making any claims about AGI. But the fact is, the models are far, far more capable then they were even 3 years ago. I think that has more to do with the harnesses we have now that it does with the models. The models are a bit better (and way bigger) but the harness is where the capability comes from. Software dev has changed significantly in most places because the fact is, this shit is useful for those tasks. People, appropriately or not, are trying to apply that to every office job basically.

I don't think that's gonna pan out for anthropic or open AI financially, especially in the long term. But there has been a lot of progress in capability in the last 2-3 years. I think they're right that if the timing works out badly, many employers could overcommit to AI and then collapse before they can correct once the bubble pops.