Spyke
lemm.ee

"I wonder why all these societal commentaries feel like society"

117

I wonder if there's a general vibe to these specific societal commentaries...

14

Oh, don't be so dramatic. We're nowhere near that yet. We're just rapidly spiraling toward it like a disoriented skydiver tangled in the lines of their reserve chute.

44
lemmy.world

Don't forget that we are actually skydiving in tandem with someone who either doesn't believe in gravity, is trying to hit the ground on purpose, or both.

19
sh.itjust.works

That person is actively stabbing at the harness with a rusty pair of shears while accusing you of sabotaging the jump. Sometimes they end up stabbing themselves, but usually they just end up stabbing you through the harness instead.

10

This is the most apt metaphor for the maga moment I’ve seen in a while. Thank you for that.

2

I like to think it wasn't even tandem, they entered the picture Point Break style.

We were skydiving. They just jumped out a plane after us.

2
sfledreply

Plunging toward oblivion while happily screaming, "10,000' so far so good, 5,000' so far so good..."

6
lemmy.blahaj.zone

Ah yes, the four cornerstones of dystopian fiction: 1984, Brave New World, Idiocracy, and Hunger Games

36
GraniteMreply
lemmy.world

I had a go at Authoritarian, Scarcity, Chaotic, and Plentiful

6

Erry day I'm broken down, erry night I recreate.

2
feddit.org

This diagram would make the same amount of sense if you randomized the titles in it.
Maybe they're already random.

30
lemmy.world

Nah, I can see it.

  • 1984: they’re rewriting history / propagandizing
  • Idiocracy: the morons are in charge
  • Hunger Games: they’re pitting us against each other
  • Brave New World: they’re distracting us with entertainment

The others seem to fall pretty well into those categories.

16
superkretreply
feddit.org

They're also rewriting history in Idiocracy (It's actually a key story element at the end).
"They're pitting us against each other" is one of the most important aspects in 1984.
And "They're distracting us with entertainment" is literally at the core of Hunger Games.

16
lemmy.world

Are you thinking of the film or the country?

The film has a large overbearing surveillance state / bureaucracy as the chief antagonist, it’s about the suppression of art and loss of human connection. Do you see it differently?

8

It's directed by Terry Gilliam, and it's brilliant. It's set in a bureaucratic totalitarian state, and follows a minor functionary who is slowly losing his mind. There are multiple overlapping plots, involving a rebel heating engineer, a man mistakenly abducted and tortured to death by the government after a computer glitch, the functionary's politically ambitious mother, a quack plastic surgeon, a beautiful truck driver, terrorist attacks, and the functionary's ever-growing escapist fantasy life. It's one of my favorite films. Right up there with Delicatessen in terms of dystopian comedy sci-fi.

8

Yeah it's not really even a joke it's just for the clapter. If someone said to you "it's like we're living in a dystopian future" it would be the same level of humor as this post.

The only thing putting it in a four-way venn diagram added was to explain to the reader that the person doesn't know how venn diagrams work.

8
lunarulreply
lemmy.world

I was wondering how Lord of the Flies fit in the Idiocracy circle.

7
SkyezOpenreply
lemmy.world

No we need to have an unnecessary 10 minute fistfight instead of just trying it for myself.

11

And in so doing, we'll have the greatest first fight ever committed to film.

5
lemmy.ca

Those films were supposed to be a warning .... NOT A GUIDE!

17
IninewCrowreply
lemmy.ca

The hookup to the Matrix in this reality is located a lot lower in the body than at the base of the neck

4

All those character names they use ... Neo, Morpheus, Trinity, Tank, Switch .... they're just Porn names for the 'Matrix'

1
lemm.ee

Throws in "Flight of the Navigator" to skip forward eight years.

8
lemmy.ca

very weak in the subgroupings. There could be 2 axises of dystopia. 1. Autocratic vs chaotic 2. some attempt to mean well vs dystopia by design.

6
ZMoneyreply
lemmy.world

Idk it doesn't look like we'll run out of food and the population bomb turned out to be a dud. Maybe the food chain will collapse in the ecocrisis, but Capital will find a way to produce food more energy-intensively to compensate.

It's a classic, but it reflects the anxieties of the time for sure.

3

I'm not convinced that tech and humanity can create enough food sources to make up for losses that climate change is going to create. I think the damage is going to occur much more quickly than any replacement food chain could be established.

5

The “you are here” is where libertarians think they and 0,0 are on a political compass meme

4

Terry Gilliam's Brazil is a masterpiece. He denies it, but anyone that has seen the movie and really knew Brazil in the eighties knows that movie is absolutely about the country.

4

Please leave The Matrix out of this. Seriously, do not compare any of that to The Matrix. It is a trans-allegory. If anything, not enough people know that. So many fucking Red Pill douchebags who would renounce the franchise once they learned that.

1

i see not even leftists are done beating the "society is just like that one overt eugenics movie" druum

1
lemmy.sdf.org

I know, I also know the movie has nothing to do with the US. And that placing this in the list is purely pejorative towards the country Brazil.

-16
lemmy.world

It’s a dystopian movie. It has literally nothing to do with the country.

10
lemmy.sdf.org

Nothing except it being called Brazil and being dystopian? Are you usually this dull?

-13

It’s named after a song. I think the main character might briefly say he dreams about going there. Obviously you haven’t seen it, but there’s really no need to get offended.

By the way, I highly recommend watching it for everyone else, especially if you’re a fan of Terry Gilliam. Not you though, guy I’m replying to. You should stick to less challenging topics to avoid hurting your own feelings.

10