Spyke

Replies

Comment on

Why is it such a crazy idea that the public should own the means of production?

Because the ruling class ideas are the ruling ideas, they control education, public spaces and media (and also the repression apparatus in case the former is insufficient). It's not about the sense of self preservation, we are not so different than ancient or medieval commoners who found questioning the divine rights of kings to own everything, a crazy idea.

The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas, i.e. the class which is the ruling material force of society, is at the same time its ruling intellectual force. The class which has the means of material production at its disposal, has control at the same time over the means of mental production, so that thereby, generally speaking, the ideas of those who lack the means of mental production are subject to it. The ruling ideas are nothing more than the ideal expression of the dominant material relationships, the dominant material relationships grasped as ideas.

― Karl Marx

Comment on

Should I Read a Brian Hebert Dune Novel?

Yes, though the level is very varying, Houses and Great Schools trilogies being quite good imo while the Heroes trilogy is, mildly speaking, bad.
There's also the Butlerian Jihad trilogy which flatten the forming event of entire setting from complicated philosophical and military conflict in which bad guys won and crippled humanity for possibly forever into an ordinary survival war against Skynet.
Or the Caladan trilogy which is honestly quite good but while it ends when the orginal Dune starts, somehow it ends up with political situation being 180 from what it should be for the original plot to happen.
And finally, there is of course the two book ending of the original cycle, which i read many times and now i'm convinced Brian didn't lie about finding the Frank stash, the books are way more similar to the original Dune books 5-6 than to rest of Brian's books (this isn't much of a compliment btw, i consider Heretics and Chapterhouse the weakest parts of original).

Comment on

Should I Read a Brian Hebert Dune Novel?

Reply in thread

Actually only 2 books are follow ups, 3 are in between of Dune and Messiah and rest are prequels, plus iirc one book of stories, that one about Gurney was quite fun. One book per year is nothing out of ordinary nowadays, that's how the publishing houses crunch authors, hell even for example Terry Pratchett was churning 1-4 books per year for most of his career. Also idk how they are dividing the work, but i would imagine most of actual writing is done by Kevin Anderson since he was a real deal crunch writer even before starting cooperation with Brian, there's two of them.
Oh and also look for the 3 volumes graphical novel of first Dune book by Raul Allen and Patricia Martin. It was directed by Brian and it is seriously the most faithful adaptation of the book ever made.

comics

Comment on

The Zionist logic

Obligatory reminder that when Polish envoy Jan Karski presented evidence of holocaust to British and US government and societal elites during his mission in 1942 and 1943 he was basically ignored.

Comment on

*Permanently Deleted*

Funko Pops

Imo they aren't getting nearly enough of hate they deserve. I'm not against figure collecting in general but FP are the ugliest motherfucking thing i ever seen in this department, for the same amount of resources, labour and energy they could produce something much better. In fact, a consistent long serie of figures faithful to the original (not ultra-deformed) across so many franchises would been great, but alas only thing there is are those unholy abominations.

comics

Comment on

XXX

"Hey Socrates, do you want to hear what one of your students just told me?"
"Wait a second, let's use my triple filter: first, is that what you heard true?"
"Well, it's more of a rumour"
"Second: is that something good?"
"Definitely not"
"Third: is that useful?"
"Not necessarily"
"So, if it's not true, good and useful then why even mention it?" Socrates goes away

Al this explains why Socrates was respected as a great philosopher. And why he never knew Plato was fucking his wife.