Spyke

Replies

Comment on

Would SpaceX continue to be immoral without Musk?

Reply in thread

The quote you gave suggests that companies are legally expected to maximise profit, but with caveats/nuance. It also highlights shareholder pressure towards the same goal.

If the claim is that fear of legal action doesn't technically count as 'legally required ", then sure, I used the wrong word. But as I said elsewhere, it doesn't change my point.

Comment on

Would SpaceX continue to be immoral without Musk?

Reply in thread

It's a consequence of the eBay vs Newmark ruling. Arguments against it are theoretical only and haven't been tested, and would be next to impossible to achieve with extant companies that don't already have advertised social priorities.

let’s be honest if it’s simply self preservation rather than some oft-cited but wrong assertion of the law.

For the purposes of my point in this discussion, the distinction doesn't matter. Whether the pressure to maximise profit over morality is a legal requirement or self preservation, the end result is inherent immorality

Comment on

Would SpaceX continue to be immoral without Musk?

Reply in thread

Companies are inherently immoral. Whether the pressure that creates that reality is from this particular case or whether it comes from self preservatio is genuinely irrelevant to my point.

Taking away Musk won't make a company moral, because all publicly traded companies are immoral.

I don't know why this particular case gets people ignoring the topic at hand to argue about it whenever it's mentioned...

Comment on

Why does it seem most people, mainly conservatives, against Trans people? Unless I am wrong I never heard of one shooting up a school church or whatever. The ones I have met have been pretty cool.

Because stirring up hate against vulnerable minorities, by positioning them as a threat is a well tested and effective technique for the power hungry to gain and retain power. And it's effective, because it works by pulling people in and making all of the conversation about whether or not it's right to hate on the group they're targeting.