Spyke
australianpolitics·Australian Politicsbyarbilp3

Pauline Hanson says Australia ‘must be monocultural’ in National Press Club speech

Congratulations Aussies, we have a Trumpette!

Australia was never monocultural and can never be monocultural. Before and during English colonisation there was a pre-existing culture on this continent which will continue into the future and will not be erased. As for European-descended colonisers, from the beginning the colony was split between Protestants and Catholics, English and Irish, ruling class and their enforcers and convicts and so on. And that's just for starters. There has never been a monoculture. There is a monocle view which makes it simple not to think.

What are your favourite (or reviled) Pauline truisms (or falsisms)?

Pauline Hanson says Australia ‘must be monocultural’ in National Press Club speechhttps://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/jun/17/pauline-hanson-national-press-club-address-speech-australia-ntwnfbOpen linkView original on aussie.zone
aussie.zone

I doubt that monoculture exists anywhere. What does that even mean? It's as nebulous as the term social cohesion. A thought terminating cliché. We're already living in different cultures based on our geographical location and class background.

28
arbilp3reply
aussie.zone

Much of what she says fits this vague, nostalgic view of the past and what the cookie cutter present should be.

12
aussie.zone

Yeah nostalgia can be distorting. It makes it worse when material conditions were actually better for many people in the past though. That has nothing to do with this monoculture idea though. And Pauline won't make material conditions better for workers.

4

That's for sure. It's just words anyway. If PHON have to front up with real policies let's see what they come up with.

4

What does that even mean?

I suspect it's a reaction to "multicultural". Their demand isn't a cohesive vision, it's a tantrum.

8

I doubt that monoculture exists anywhere. What does that even mean?

Read it as monochrome culture and it makes much more sense.

1
aussie.zone

Besides which unless we do some pretty awful stuff it’s probably impossible to achieve. It’s unbelievably diverse for our population.

1

The kind of monoculture I'd like to see is one that priotises wages over asset growth. I suppose that would be awful for asset owners, but I'm sure they'll be OK.

5

That's not even the real story here. The real story is that the party of freedom and anti woke is having a sook and wants to use police resources to arrest the person who did it... Over a piece of paper that literally showed a real fact

Almost like a dictatorship would against their political opponents.

14
Cypherreply
aussie.zone

What do you mean? All Aboriginals practiced welcome to country ceremonies like some sort of monoculture

-8

I think you may be ribbing but if you're not, do a bit of reading and you will find that clan or tribal groups had different protocols for acknowledging visitors to the country over which they were custodians depending on their local traditions. It was a way for both visitors to identify themselves and for the custodians of that part of the country to welcome them and express their culture. At the time of European settlement there were about 250 indigenous languages with about 500 dialects, so, language being part of culture already tells you that there was a lot of diversity and not a sort of monoculture.

1
feddit.org

All of the above, plus today monoculture is recognized as a bad thing (agriculturally speaking). Can't she even find a good metaphor?

8

That's the first thing I thought of too, the agricultural meaning, and how monoculture is bad for the land and for living beings. She either does not have enough understanding to see the implications of what she's saying, or, she wants to stir the pot to get lots of attention and social media action.

3

And I suppose it's her culture and she is going to impose it on everyone, whether they like it or not

she and her oppressive intolerant mates can eff off

8
lemmy.world

I wonder what she thinks of the national anthem...

...One and free...Boundless plains to share....

4
aussie.zone

Same here, no idea this was done

I’ve always wanted just didge for it. Nothing else, just didge, for however long necessary. 10 seconds is enough for a sports national anthem.

Nothing else is needed, it tells the whole story.

4
notgoldreply
aussie.zone

I'm happy for some didge but there's nothing like singing aaf at the top of your lungs at the mcg

1
aussie.zone

What the anthem? I can’t sing it, I just can’t, it’s awful

I’m biased though, I don’t really like any

2

Advance Australia Fair. I also like hearing the Kiwi anthem using Maori and English. Can't sing that one yet though

2

I mean its kinda cool folks keeping up cultural traditions but monoculture is boring. Its great being in a city where you have a chinese area, and indian, and korean, and irish, and polish, and german, and ukrainian, and just everything.

4

You reached the end

Pauline Hanson says Australia ‘must be monocultural’ in National Press Club speech | Spyke