FR: See All Replies
I reply to a comment.
Later, I want to see other discussion around the comment--who else replied, what they said, etc.
As far as I can tell, there is no easy way to do this. If I See Parent Comment, or whatever, it keeps me locked into that chain of replies and I cannot see anybody elses replies unless they are beneath my comment.
My only options are: 1-View all comments and find the original comment there. 2-Go to the user's profile and find the comment, click on it, be brought back to thread at that comment (this is what I'd like to do with a single click).
This used to be a feature on a reddit (maybe it was called "go to comment"), but disappeared in the enshittifification.
Edit: Clarification:
What I want to see:
Comment A
= A Reply to Comment A
= = Reply to reply to comment A
= My Reply to Comment A
= = Reply to My Comment
= Yet Another Reply to Comment A
Right now, the best I can easily do is:
Comment A
= My Comment
= =Reply to My Comment
I may not be following what you’re asking for, but if I go to my profile where my comments are listed and tap one of my comments I see all the replies to that comment.
Are you trying to get to siblings of your comment instead of its children?
I want to see the replies to the comment I replied to (aka siblings of my comment?)
What I want to see:
Comment A
= A Reply to Comment A
= = Reply to reply to comment A
= My Reply to Comment A
= = Reply to My Comment
= Yet Another Reply to Comment A
Right know, the best I can easily do is:
Comment A
= My Comment
= =Reply to My Comment
I want to know how the rest of the conversation is going, in other words. Do people have the same ideas, am I repeating information, am I at odds with the rest of the community, etc....
:
Reddit does still have this feature if you use the old.reddit.com interface. It’s called “Context” and shows the parent comment to your comment and all its child comments including yours.
Back when I used Reddit, I used this all the time and also missed it in Lemmy when I first switched. I had actually forgotten about this but would love to have this feature too.
If I'm understanding correctly, Jerboa has this button as well, to walk up the tree one step at a time basically. So it shouldn't be impossible
Does every comment have a url with all its children?
I think so?
e.g. This is the URL Voyager gave me when I long pressed your first reply to my first comment and chose “Share”:
https://sh.itjust.works/comment/25798701
Perfect! So all it would be is link with a label in the hamburger menu. What label are you thinking? Context is ambiguous, “Go to Comment” is clearest for me.
I don’t like “Context” either but I see how you get there.
“Go to Comment” is wrong, IMO, because it suggests going to the comment itself; not the parent.
“Parent Comment” is good, but what if the parent is a Post rather than a Comment
You could change based on parent type, but “Parent Post” sounds weird; simplifying to “Post” doesn’t work because of verb confusion.
So “Context” seems best to me of those options…
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I go to my profile and click my comment. I can see the parent comment I replied to, my reply, replies to me, and replies to those replies.
Have another look at my comment; I think I finally formatted it correctly
Ah, I see now. Sibling comments to your comment do indeed not display.
I usually tap a comment, click share, copy link, then go to search tab and paste the url. Tap the comment and then see the context of the thread.
Its roundabout but also pretty rare flow, at least for me.