Spyke

Best movie, or best WW2 movie? Which is a better representation of the war? The experiences of the soldiers? Which has better art direction and writing and acting? Which one is a better reflection of the current zeitgeist?

I don't have answers, I just feel like "better" has a lot of dimensions.

11

The best (as in, most realistic) world war 2 movie is Come And See.
It shows the war from the side that most suffered from it, the Russian population.
80% of the war happened inside Russia.

4

Haven't seen this but have heard this title for decades. One day, I'll have the strength to take this film on.

2

I like both, but as I've gotten older the philosophical approach of Malick's film has begun to really resonate.

1
  • The Pianist

  • Empire of the Sun

  • The End of the Affair

  • 火垂るの墓 — "The Grave of the Fireflies"

  • La Vita e Bella — "Life is Beautiful"

Less about how the front lines and the warriors fared. More about how the wars affected individuals, particularly children.

1

"The Day the Clown Cried" was released from the library of Congress last year but I haven't seen a copy so I don't know where it rates.

1

You reached the end

When I was young I thought the best WW2 movie was Saving Private Ryan. As I have aged I realized it was the The Thin Red Line all the time | Spyke