I had enough of big tech and their actions, so created this guide to make switching as easy as possible
I shared a version of this guide earlier this year, but felt a website was needed to unpack the different options fully. So after an unreasonable number of hours, I put together the necessary data and website.
I hope this is digestible enough for the average person to help those looking to take that first step, or for people who are equally passionate and want to get their friends or family involved.
Details:
- Site - https://purchasewithpurpose.io/
- Code - https://codeberg.org/purchase-with-purpose/pwp-website
- Community - https://lemmy.world/c/PurchaseWithPurpose
Every time I post these guides, there is always feedback on things that can improve, or I got wrong. Please do share, as it is the best way for these to evolve!
499
Comments128
Nice guide! Lemmy is missing though 🐭. Also, what's the point of moving from Twitter to BlueSky? They are no different. Mastodon is a great option.
I haven't been too focused on Social Media given that it is less about features and more about community. But will look at adding a Reddit replacement.
KDE is friendlier to Windows users than GNOME, but Mint is still a good option.
And KDE is predominately German.
I see Qobuz on there. IMHO, Bandcamp should be your first stop when buying music. If it's not on bandcamp, Qobuz seems to have just about everything else, more or less, that someone might want. I've complained about them in the past for making me download my purchases one track at a time, which can be pretty annoying if you're buying a super-duper-deluxe version of an album, but, I am pleased to say, they no longer do this; you can download the complete albums you've purchased in a zip file. But only once. Stuff can disappear for annoying rights reasons, and I think they even say, once you buy your music download it immediately, because it may not be there on a subsequent visit.
I’m not so sure. Last time I looked for an album it was cheaper on Qobuz than Bandcamp - also Qobuz had a Hi-Res version. Bandcamp I think takes 15% + payment handling which seems a lot for being a shopfront. I went to record label to get it in the end as I thought that was probably the best way of getting the money to the artist.
I am very bothered by the OS section. Bazzite should be the go-to for gaming, period. Ubuntu should never be recommended to anyone. Fedora is far more stable and reliable as a starter distro than either Mint or Ubuntu. Fedora Workstation for Mac expats and Fedora KDE for Windows expats.
I won’t fault anyone for putting Mint in there, but I loathe Cinnamon and would never recommend a distro that excludes KDE by design.
agreed, bazzite, nobara, and cachyOS would all have been better alternatives to popOS
I'd normally have Pop as as more of a starter distro, although I haven't been recommending it lately just because it's in a bit of an awkward spot in crossing over from GNOME to COSMIC. Not that I dislike COSMIC, I just wouldn't want a newbie to install the GNOME version and then have to go through switching their whole DE right off the bat.
COSMIC is supposed to hit 1.0 in the next few days and I’m looking forward to it. I wouldn’t recommend it right now only because the beta still has too many rough edges. Once it’s more polished, Pop_OS it could be an excellent starter distro.
I think a lot of these guides could use more in-depth companion guides to go along with it. Changing your email provider for one is not a simple thing and there are concerns like loss of functionality (Gmail is a good product run by a shit company) and also how to make the process less overwhelming. Some services will give you the option to migrate all your emails from Gmail but maybe you want to start fresh, etc. Then there's going to all of your providers and updating your contact email. Again, not as simple as signing up for another service.
I have started on that with a small intro section for most sections (still adding). An example is email https://purchasewithpurpose.eu/category/email, but I understand that an even more in-depth guide is warranted.
Thanks for making these! The mix of thorough structured data and qualitative disclaimers is so useful.
I’ve been curious about Infomaniak because I haven’t seen much about it until recently. Is “Open Source” the main reason Tuta and Proton are on the infographic instead?
I use Infomaniak for my email and cloud storage.
They’re great, but lately their Linux app has had problems.
When I reported it, they were really efficient and friendly.
Also their data centers are heating buildings where I live.
I would always recommand them as they offer really good prices too.
I tried to limit it to 3-4 per section, and the email category was already so full - no specific reason. That said, I've since learned that Tuta's free tier is a bit limited, so I might actually switch to Infomaniak Mail instead.
Proton Sheets will save us all... Right?
LibreWolf browser
Agreed! It is an excellent choice and is part of the recommended list on the website. https://purchasewithpurpose.io/category/browser/
Where are the password managers? When changing your accounts to another email provider, this is a really good time to also make sure all the accounts have a strong, unique password or phrase.
That is true; I am planning to do Password Managers next, but can see now why it would have made sense to include them sooner.
Well, a short guide to make your own unique passwords that are strong, and that you are able to memorize, would be enough there... Otherwise, Firefox has a build in password manager.
For frequently accessed sites that will work but what about a site that is only needed once a year? Password managers secure a lot more than passwords.
Oh, what do they secure more?
I have a system, I do change it sometimes, and it's simple for me to remember, but makes strong passwords.
Security questions. For me to log into my income tax portal, I need to answer 1 of 5 questions. None of the answers to their questions are something that can be looked up in breach data - for example "Name your first love" my answer could be "the moon". I log into this once a year so forgetting my fake answers is a real possibility.
Medical information about my family such as current prescriptions and allergies.
My password manager also can create email aliases.
Basically, anything that needs to be kept secure, private, and accessible.
Here's a simple question. Isn't 2-factor login safer than what you describe there?
Why would you need aliases? Do you often login to places that is so insecure?
Well, seems like you have a hard time with security. Me, I manage with 2-factor and my password system, that makes me have unique passwords for every site or app I need... :-)
2FA isn't an option for my income tax portal but would be a safer option.
Aliases are used so I never share my actual email address. If any service I sign up with starts spamming, I know that email has been compromised (probably in a breach) or the service spams their users.
Security is very easy for me. Password managers are the norm among the privacy/security community.
And yet some of those managers has been breached and is continuously targeted, because they are a security risk in themselves.
Strange to have a tax portal with poor security.
Reddit -> Lemmy is a recent switch that I'm happy with
I just tries Lemmy now instead of Reddit 👍
I don't know where this would fit in on the website but one company that is really important to boycott is Oracle. Larry Ellison is a mega right-wing donor and his son is buying up media companies for the purposes of turning them into right-wing propaganda machines.
One way everyone can make a difference is by uninstalling any Oracle software on your computer. You might have the Oracle JRE installed or if you're into virtualization you may be using Virtualbox. It's especially important to avoid Oracle software in a corporate setting because their lawyers may come after you. If you work for a company and you're either involved in purchasing software or a software developer I would strongly recommend avoiding Oracle not just because of ethical reasons but also because typically they have their products are not as good from a technical standpoint as well.
For the Oracle JRE or JDK you can replace it with Adoptium. Adoptium is run by the Eclipse Foundation which is based in the EU.
For Virtualbox you can replace it with QEMU or Xen. For QEMU there are a lot of good GUI or CLI front-ends that make using it easy. See this article: https://wiki.gentoo.org/wiki/QEMU/Front-ends note that some of the front-ends listing in that article also support Xen.
For Oracle's database some say that PostgreSQL is a good competitor. For this one I acknowledge the topic is more complex. I'm just going to leave it at for new designs please consider avoiding Oracle's database if you can. Oracle has a bad reputation among programmers for a reason.
Oracle definitely fits under the tech giants to boycott.... and also fuck Larry Ellison. Will keep this in mind for future tools, but feel free to post this on https://lemmy.world/c/PurchaseWithPurpose in the meantime.
I posted it there! Before I was worried to post there because I didn't see any recent posts.
I was just thinking, one way to start adding Oracle might be to create a Database section and mention Oracle's database and perhaps other closed source/bad solutions like Access and suggest open source alternatives like PostgreSQL and MariaDB.
I use the VirtualBox stuff all the time! Time to look for a replacement..
If someone uses Oracle DB I can only pray for their soul 🙏
Correction: Ente is also self-hostable.
Sorry, I did include that on the website https://purchasewithpurpose.eu/software/49nBOpWnyCdLNGVJ71k6SJ/ - but forgot to update the guide.
Here is my set up:
My set up:
This is me, but i did it in reverse. Once windows was behind me it kind of opened up the door to more change. Took me less than a year to arrive at not using my google account at all.
Thanks for putting this together. Stuff like this is good for making it more approachable. I definitely have relatives that would benefit from this.
One note though, it would be good if the key included all of the icons and not just the three causes.
As the other commented pointed out, it would also be good to differentiate decentralized services, for example in the category with Mastodon and Bluesky.
Agreed, I'll look to update the main guide infographic with all the causes. The website itself has these listed, though, if you prefer to share that.
In your guide, Proton's services have the EU flag, but the company is Swiss.
It is supposed to represent a European company. But will update it as it is confusing.
I'm not Swiss, but I've understood that Switzerland adopts many EU laws, but not all of them. I've also heard that a right-wing party, which wants the country to be more independent from the EU is pretty popular there.
As this is just based on things that I've heard, I don't have any sources to link.
What I mean is, Switzerland is an European country, but as I've understood, any specific EU law or regulation may or may not apply.
Great guide! Very useful for people discovering a world outside of the GAFAM’s.
I’ve done everything, but leaving Whatsapp is the most difficult one. I use Threema and Signal with my close friends, but I can’t get rid of Whatsapp because of many groups I have to follow but I’m not close enough to people to ask them to switch.
I’d love it if these two chat services proposed a separate app which would be interoperable with Whatsapp.
Yes Meta would still get some of my data, but less than if I had Whatsapp directly.
Also getting Whatsapp business and setting an automatic answer asking people to contact me through mail, sms or other chats is useful.
Leaving youtube is also difficult as Peertube is lacking non tech content like basketball..
Thanks! Social media is by far the hardest and will be the last hurdle to tackle. Right now, I am focusing more on getting people to move tools. Btw, if you didn't already see, the website is even more helpful than the guide itself - in case you ever want to get others to make the switch. https://purchasewithpurpose.io/
I stopped looking at it after initial glance, seeing the top line, the browsers.
Vivaldi?
Really.
No.
what's wrong with vivaldi? they're european. they have zero ai in their browser. and they're one of the few browser with a build in ad/tracker blocker that supports adblock filters.
it's proprietary/closed-source
And thus cannot readily be audited.
And thus attracts malarchy and malware being put in it.
Fully free software or gtfo.
Probably because it's another browser based on Chromium.
That's not a justification to make it closed source. Brave is open source and based on chromium.
Yup. Or any of many other examples, all the way to qutebrowser.
That does not help, but is a side matter.
Original reddit post, because I didn't trust this guy to be telling the truth
https://www.reddit.com/r/degoogle/comments/1jcqvu0/your_guide_to_move_away_from_big_tech_and_support/
A more recent one on lemmy.word as well :) I've been at this for a long time and as you can see, it has come a long way since that first version. https://lemmy.world/post/28524939
Thank you! Fuck Google!!!
Replace Ubuntu with Zorin OS
I think waterfox was sold to an ad agency.
In 2020 System1 bought Waterfox, the same company with a controlling interesting in Startpage.
In 2023 Waterfox became independent from System1.
According to their Wikipedia page https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/System1
Not anymore, it is mentioned on their profile. They are now owned by the founder again. https://purchasewithpurpose.eu/software/5RBGtGMEiI5J7DDaaMrfuZ/
@FallenWalnut @zakobjoa
That's correct. I love me some Waterfox...my browser of choice. Though I really like Vivaldi too
What stumped me is that YouTube music and apple music are the starting point, and not Spotify.
Also isn't using your own Mailserver with your own domain on any webhoster plus Thunderbird a viable alternative? I've been doing this for like 20 years. That's the beauty of email imo
The website has the space to cover these topics far better. Spotify has a big red disclaimer against it to educate people on why not to use it - https://purchasewithpurpose.io/software/D5JUoM1dZysf7JJgTAWXy/ Email category tries to explain how you can use email clients fit into the picture and lists Thunderbird - https://purchasewithpurpose.io/category/email
Firefox is big tech
... weeeell... It's big tech in some ways, but not really...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Tech
Someone posted Narrow32 on lemmy then when I was trying it out I discovered Duckduckgo lite. Now it's my default search. Brings me back to when Google was a search engine.
Hadn't heard of Marginalia search. Will look to include that on the website :)
I can use marginalia as default search for Firefox!
Anyone have an alternative for Google Keep? I just want shared notes and checklists across all my devices
Joplin maybe?
On the list, will get there maybe in 2-3 weeks time! But if you want something sooner, maybe post on the community https://lemmy.world/c/PurchaseWithPurpose
I recommend notesnook
Upnote or check out a new one called Lockbook
If you need markdown and other formatting you can use notion.so, but I can't expect that company will be good in the future even though they're good now. They've already added AI. I use it for a note-taking because I can create hyperlinks between notes.
Why does every search engine look exactly the same, and push the exact same AI chat feature, and have identical options for filtering arranged in out in the exact same order in the exact same location.
I think there's only one search engine.
Probably because it's the same use case?
That's like asking why all keyboards have the same letters in the same arrangement, with mostly the same options.
If you want something different, try Kagi. It has other controls you don't see elsewhere
People are all copying what they are familiar with, and that is Google. I list the providers that have AI Summaries as part of their offering; you can find one that doesn't. https://purchasewithpurpose.io/category/search-engine/
I also like OnlyOffice as an alternative to MSOffice/Google Office Suite, has free tiers and real-time sessions
Yup, an excellent option and it is listed on the site. https://purchasewithpurpose.io/category/office-suite/
It is worth noting the potential ties to Russia as that has been a deal breaker for some.
Why Tidal? I get the part against apple, but why tidal?
It is hard for me to be the arbiter of what tools are ethical enough, so I try to make these facts as easy as possible to find for people. In the end, it educates and ultimately most decide against using such tools (for example, Spotify). There is a note on Tidal's profile about Jack Dorsey's and Jay-Z's involvement. https://purchasewithpurpose.io/software/34R8h9DOVPhaJ7CZMmKW48/
That's kinda why I was asking I remember something about Dorsey a while a go
Spotify often gets bad press, some probably promoted by competitors. Its payouts look lower mainly because it offers a free ad-supported tier and serves markets with lower subscription fees - if it were subscription-only in high-fee markets, payouts would be similar to Apple, Tidal, or Qobuz. Also, I haven’t seen Spotify play me any AI-generated tracks, unlike some other platforms.
What about https://www.privacyguides.org/en/ ?
Doesn't that already serve the same purpose? ... without also recommending to use a closed source browser as Vivaldi like you are doing instead?
Privacyguides is an excellent resource, and in fact, it is often linked on the website. You might be interested in https://privacy.purchasewithpurpose.io/, which prioritises tools validated by them.
However, it isn't meant to serve the same audience. PurchaseWithPurpose is there to make moving more digestible for the average user, while educating them on more advanced topics.
how do I take multiple emails and consolidate them into one ? thats the biggest thing preventing me from degoogling gmail
Thunderbird can do something like this! It's called 'Unified folders' on desktop and 'Unified Inbox' on mobile I think? But essentially it takes all your inboxes and makes them into a single folder.
you should never use "just one" email. I would find a service that you can have one main account and have a a few aliases.
That's cool and all but that doesn't solve my issue of not wanting to use 6+ Gmail accounts, I need to consolidate their inboxes or I can't move away from Gmail
When you select a new email provider check to see if they have a migration tool. For example, I use spacemail and they have this: https://www.spaceship.com/business-email/migrate-business-email/
Not entirely sure of your situation. So you have 6+ Gmail accounts and want a service that can import them into a single account?
I could probably look into it but more so hoping anyone has any ideas or experience as to consolidate the inboxes (keeping incoming emails) into 1 inbox or whatever other strategy would work
That's how aliases work. Pretty much all of the services listed here - https://purchasewithpurpose.io/category/email/ - have them. You can have multiple email addresses, but yet they all go to the same inbox.
As a strategy to minimize your effort in the migration, start by forwarding all your Gmail accounts to the corresponding inbox and/or alias. You can then start using the new service right away and take as long as you need to migrate your accounts across.
Perfect, so there is a way to forward incoming emails right?
I wasn't thinking of aliases but using aliases as the address to forward to is pretty smart
Thanks to you I was able to forward all incoming stuff from Gmail into aliased inboxes
cheers
Glad to hear you came right! Most new email providers have an onboarding process to help with this. Feel free to post on https://lemmy.world/c/PurchaseWithPurpose if you ever get stuck.
Thanks for the feedback! The website goes into this level of detail and includes some of those suggestions you had: https://purchasewithpurpose.io/
Hard to include all of this in the graphic alone, but will consider how it can be improved.
y no searxng?
They are on the website :) Just too many options to include them all on the infographic. https://purchasewithpurpose.io/category/search-engine/
Session is great for messaging! Should’ve included it. Other than that, great guide :)
there an alternative for google maps?
Thanks for this, I've been slowly trying to move to new services now I'm just waiting to get a new phone that can be De-Google'd
It's not just the EU flag, it's the flag of Europe.
It is technically supposed to represent Europe, but maybe I'll replace it simply with UKs flag. Thanks for flagging.
Gotta love promoting Electron slop like Element right next to stuff claiming sustainability
Why avoid Safari if it’s one of the browsers with best privacy rating?
While privacy may be fine, I think Apple as a company is pretty deplorable.
It technically isn't. There are better browsers for that. That said, the ultimate goal of these guides is to move away from big tech, so it won't help going from one to the other.
If that isn't a concern of yours, then no need to more.
But I don’t get Beave that is selling user data is being recommended instead of Safari https://stackdiary.com/brave-selling-copyrighted-data-for-ai-training/
Brave certainly doesn't come recommended. They are shown as they are a well-known option, but a big disclaimer is included to educate people on why not to use them: https://purchasewithpurpose.eu/software/3vx2w2oHoySUVasOnOa3aV/
Safari isn't open source. They could in theory add a backdoor anytime and it would be more difficult to audit.
WebKit is open source, Safari is just a front end for it.
I was gonna object to having the OS be on week 9 but then I noticed almost all of these are just webapps. Weird times
Thank you for this guide, as I go into the new year I wanna push for my own personal degoogle and removing big tech out of my life. This has been a great help so far.
What’s wrong with Safari?
Missed that part?
i thought you had stopped recommending protonmail and spotify but i see now both are back (spotify not in this image, but (with caveats) on your website).
i see you've been making these images for many years and obviously put a lot of time in to it - i assume that like most other ethical consumerism campaigns you must have some funding for it? (from who?)
The guide has had many iterations, and you are right that at one point, they were entirely removed. I've ended up informing rather than hiding, as most of these names are already known, whereas not many people are aware of Spotify's actions (for example). Proton is a little more complicated - I personally won't use them, but I can see the nuance where some people might.
I don't get any funding. I am a developer myself, so I do 80% of the work. The rest is self-funded and will continue for the foreseeable future.
i don't understand what motivates you to do so much unpaid labor to market/advertise/recommend commercial products and services which you yourself would not even use.
You're kind of described almost the entirety of FOSS. It only exists because there are talented people who make shit and give it away for free.
yeah - but it's not hard to understand the motivation to do unpaid labor to develop (and promote) FOSS - it's the promotion of proprietary things (many if not most of which i infer OP doesn't even use themself) which baffles me.
if OP truly isn't getting paid by any of these companies for making posts like this then they're leaving money on the table, because many of the companies behind the proprietary products and services they're recommending do spend a substantial amount on marketing.
Bazzite is the go-to OS for Linux gaming for most new systems now. Even tech brands are promoting it.
Never heard of PopOS as a gaming distro.
Sorry I really could have researched that category better. You aren't the first one to point it out. Will look to update.
The choice of Linux distro is a major battlefield. You couldn't have gotten to any answer that wouldn't invite complaints.
Just wanna say thanks for updating it, my 2c is also to add Spotify in the music section as the starting point to move away from
Personally, I agree and have in the past put it in the left column. Right now I have settled for having a disclaimer against its name and might make that more prominent in the overview pages as well. https://purchasewithpurpose.eu/software/D5JUoM1dZysf7JJgTAWXy/