Probably Ted the Caver for me. I feel like a lot of creepypastas go way overboard in trying to pull the rug out from under you in a gotcha moment or straight up just making an OC don't steal, but I always thought the more grounded and minimalist creepypastas did a better job.
6 replies
Probably Ted the Caver for me. I feel like a lot of creepypastas go way overboard in trying to pull the rug out from under you in a gotcha moment or straight up just making an OC don't steal, but I always thought the more grounded and minimalist creepypastas did a better job.
Ted the Caver is seared into my memory. Highly recommend reading it.
Anansi's Goatman Story
Fuck that story! Haha got me and my friends so good and we started out in the middle of nowhere camping as a joke. No sleep was had by all.
Ted the Caver is my top one, but Eric the Pie is a close second.
Mine would have to be Penpal.
https://creepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/Penpal