I really enjoyed Tyranny, not exactly scrolls-like but the story felt ES like.

Deserved, really solid series thus far.

I'm not trying to edition war, I think 5th, after some errata and additional books, is really in an excellent spot. I do think it would have been a disservice to the story to not mention how controversial 5e was (and we'll probably get to see that again in a month when we get Werewolf 5th).

I am collecting a list of White Wolf's various controversies and blunders, other editions and lines will get their shaming in a month or so when I finish my research.

5% is a big miss. It could effect their next earnings prediction