Well, in Portugal a smallish group set up a peaceful tent camp in a square in Porto and the Municipal Police, apparently under orders from the Mayor (equivalent to "Mayor", the position here is actually "City Hall President") did a police charge on the demonstrators and the whole thing ended up on TV.
This was followed by big demonstrations, both in Porto and Lisbon, as well as much bigger encampments, this time in both.
Note that said Mayor is from the same political party as the Government, which is a rightwing part that was formed after the 1974 Revolution by the sons and daughters of those who had wealthy and priviledge under Fascism, and who have just passed a law to further reduce protections for renters in effect making it much more likely that what happenned to Maricarmen in next door Spain would also happen here.
Mind you the current situation of low salaries together with insane house prices and rents was created by governments of both that party and the "left" (but not really left, not since the 80s) mainstream party which have pretty much alternated in power ever since not long after the 74 Revolution.
Mind you, the problem of high costs of living - especially housing - and low incomes along with successive governments whose policies actually incentivise realestate bubbles is happening in almost all of Europe. I just mentioned this because it's funny how the idiot Mayor by acting like an autoritarian made the situation explode, similarly to how the violence in France exploded when the police used excessive force against children demonstration (though it's not violent yet in Portugal)
The fact that Porto city is like 80% a UNESCO heritage sight and the local residents need a ton of paperwork and money to get basic repairs done (on top of the crazy property bubble) is just nuts. Porto was the purest form of neoliberalism on steroids I've ever seen.
The Prime Minister of Portugal is known for owning 55 realestate properties.
Some years ago already, a third of the city council members in Lisbon declared "realestate investor" as their second job.
Realestate investment is quite common amongst members of Parliament here, especially the ones not from Lisbon as they get a pretty much unlimited subsidy to pay rent for a place to live in Lisbon, so they move to Lisbon and rent their old home in the region (outside Lisbon) they came from and represent which starts them down that path if they were not already.
Obviously none of these people will do anything in any way form or shape to stop house prices (and hence rents) from going up. In fact quite the contrary: the current government recently passed a law reducing renter rights and last year their measure for, they claimed, "help young people buy their first house" - state guaranteed loans to buy a first house - resulted in a 17% house price spike just that year, exactly the same kind of outcome as the last time a similar measure was enacted (so either they're complete total incompetent morons or a spike in house prices was the intention behind that measure).
Talking about southern Europe, for years people have been warning politicians and all institutions that the housing situation was unsustainable. They were ignored as always, the numbers were helping their agenda.
Now we see the big cracks showing up. Will they listen? or let the situation aggravate?
More (public) housing needs to be built, taxes need to be raised (by a lot) for vacant homes and non-primary residences, and a better supervision should be put in place to avoid tax evasion.
Will European countries have the will to do what is required?
I'm in Portugal and it's hilarious (well, more like infuriating, really) that even the supposedly thinking Left (I'm a member of a small such party here and am thoroughly dissapointed with its leadership) haven't connected the dots yet on a problem which has been painfully obvious for more than a decade:
The big problem of "low birth rates" and hence aging population of the country which in turn ends up cascading into all sorts of other problems (for example, an overloaded National Health Service because an aged population need a lot more healthcare services) and even justifies immigration (as a way to bring in working age adults to produce wealth here) can be pretty directly traced back to high house prices making people leave their parent's house much later (here in Portugal the average age for that is 34 years old!), thus having children much later which usually means fewer and because upsizing their home to have more children is also harder that too means fewer children, with the result that the average number of children per-family here is 1.8 when the replacement rate is 2.4 children.
I mean, even the far-right anti-immigration muppets would logically want lower housing costs so that the locals have more kids and no foreigners need come so that there's still people working to pay their pensions.
And don't get me started on how at this point half the young adults who get University degrees leave the country as soon as they get their degree, another thing which itself also feeds into things like a National Health Service under pressure (as many of those who leave are trained Doctors and Nurses).
Meanwhile, an ever greater fraction of ruling politicians have as a second job "realestate investor" - for example the Prime Minister here in Portugal is well know for owning 55 properties - so they have very clear personal incentives to make policies which result in realestate prices increases since that makes them wealthier (and screw everybody else), which in turn makes the situation of the country worse at many levels.
They'd let the situation aggravate and then blame it on immigrants and focus only on the violence of the few bad actors taking advantage of the situation. You can count on governments doing the wrong thing.
3
‘We are suffocating’: protests spread to Lisbon and Milan as housing and living cost tensions intensify | Spyke
8 replies
Well, in Portugal a smallish group set up a peaceful tent camp in a square in Porto and the Municipal Police, apparently under orders from the Mayor (equivalent to "Mayor", the position here is actually "City Hall President") did a police charge on the demonstrators and the whole thing ended up on TV.
This was followed by big demonstrations, both in Porto and Lisbon, as well as much bigger encampments, this time in both.
Note that said Mayor is from the same political party as the Government, which is a rightwing part that was formed after the 1974 Revolution by the sons and daughters of those who had wealthy and priviledge under Fascism, and who have just passed a law to further reduce protections for renters in effect making it much more likely that what happenned to Maricarmen in next door Spain would also happen here.
Mind you the current situation of low salaries together with insane house prices and rents was created by governments of both that party and the "left" (but not really left, not since the 80s) mainstream party which have pretty much alternated in power ever since not long after the 74 Revolution.
Mind you, the problem of high costs of living - especially housing - and low incomes along with successive governments whose policies actually incentivise realestate bubbles is happening in almost all of Europe. I just mentioned this because it's funny how the idiot Mayor by acting like an autoritarian made the situation explode, similarly to how the violence in France exploded when the police used excessive force against children demonstration (though it's not violent yet in Portugal)
The fact that Porto city is like 80% a UNESCO heritage sight and the local residents need a ton of paperwork and money to get basic repairs done (on top of the crazy property bubble) is just nuts. Porto was the purest form of neoliberalism on steroids I've ever seen.
Yah, but to open a "souvenir" shop you don't need that paperwork
Maybe they can build tents from landlords? Stop treating housing as an investment. Devalue housing and start building.
The Prime Minister of Portugal is known for owning 55 realestate properties.
Some years ago already, a third of the city council members in Lisbon declared "realestate investor" as their second job.
Realestate investment is quite common amongst members of Parliament here, especially the ones not from Lisbon as they get a pretty much unlimited subsidy to pay rent for a place to live in Lisbon, so they move to Lisbon and rent their old home in the region (outside Lisbon) they came from and represent which starts them down that path if they were not already.
Obviously none of these people will do anything in any way form or shape to stop house prices (and hence rents) from going up. In fact quite the contrary: the current government recently passed a law reducing renter rights and last year their measure for, they claimed, "help young people buy their first house" - state guaranteed loans to buy a first house - resulted in a 17% house price spike just that year, exactly the same kind of outcome as the last time a similar measure was enacted (so either they're complete total incompetent morons or a spike in house prices was the intention behind that measure).
Talking about southern Europe, for years people have been warning politicians and all institutions that the housing situation was unsustainable. They were ignored as always, the numbers were helping their agenda.
Now we see the big cracks showing up. Will they listen? or let the situation aggravate?
More (public) housing needs to be built, taxes need to be raised (by a lot) for vacant homes and non-primary residences, and a better supervision should be put in place to avoid tax evasion.
Will European countries have the will to do what is required?
I'm in Portugal and it's hilarious (well, more like infuriating, really) that even the supposedly thinking Left (I'm a member of a small such party here and am thoroughly dissapointed with its leadership) haven't connected the dots yet on a problem which has been painfully obvious for more than a decade:
I mean, even the far-right anti-immigration muppets would logically want lower housing costs so that the locals have more kids and no foreigners need come so that there's still people working to pay their pensions.
And don't get me started on how at this point half the young adults who get University degrees leave the country as soon as they get their degree, another thing which itself also feeds into things like a National Health Service under pressure (as many of those who leave are trained Doctors and Nurses).
Meanwhile, an ever greater fraction of ruling politicians have as a second job "realestate investor" - for example the Prime Minister here in Portugal is well know for owning 55 properties - so they have very clear personal incentives to make policies which result in realestate prices increases since that makes them wealthier (and screw everybody else), which in turn makes the situation of the country worse at many levels.
They'd let the situation aggravate and then blame it on immigrants and focus only on the violence of the few bad actors taking advantage of the situation. You can count on governments doing the wrong thing.