Unfortunately laws don't automatically apply inside private homes to women, children and other vulnerable people who are most ofter exploited by religious nonsense like this. They need to be enforced in some way.
Yeah I just looked up what Shariah law is and people should be free to observe practices voluntarily as a religion, but religious law should not be permitted to override equal civil rights or be imposed coercively on people who do not consent to it.
A 2013 report by the Brennan Center for Justice warned that the bans may have the unintended effects of invalidating prenuptial agreements and court decisions made in other states where arbitrators may have taken into account Islamic, Jewish, or Christian legal norms. Randy Brinson, the president of the Christian Coalition of Alabama, criticized the ban in Alabama, calling it "redundant and a waste of time".
...
According to Sadakat Kadri, the ban on sharia laws notwithstanding, "the precepts of Islamic law ... have judicial force in the United States already", among Muslims who have had a dispute settled by Muslim conciliators. The 1925 Federal Arbitration Act allows Muslims, Christians, Jews, etc. to use religious tribunals to arbitrate disagreements and "the judgments that result are given force of law by state and federal courts". The statute "preempts inconsistent state legislation", such as laws to ban sharia.
While the US Congress could in theory repeal the act, it could not ban arbitration by Muslims while leaving other religious conciliators free to continue their work. "Any reform would have to impact equally on all faith communities, and it is not only Muslims who would object if federal legislators presumed to do that."
Legislatures continue to revisit the issue: Texas enacted a law aimed at preventing residential developments it characterized as “Sharia compounds,” and Arizona lawmakers in 2026 moved to ban any court recognition of Sharia despite no evidence of its use in the state’s courts
Increasingly, these prohibitions on "Sharia" begin to look like attempts by the state to harass Muslim religious communities and interrupt secular land development and business activity.
finally someone saying culture war is pointless because conservatives are using it to hurt minorities, instead of criticising left wingers for treating lgbt people's rights as important
What would conservatives/regressives do with their time if they weren't making themselves victims while actively violating the Constitution by persecuting those that they don't view as equal?
Won't you please think about conservative/regressive feelings? It's all they're thinking about.
15 replies
Christianity is engaged in their own form of sharia law, with this admin.
I think we can just call it all Abrahamic Law and lump it into the same thing.
Moreover, it isnt that it protects religious laws.
It protects everyone else from having said religious laws forced on them. In theory.
Unfortunately laws don't automatically apply inside private homes to women, children and other vulnerable people who are most ofter exploited by religious nonsense like this. They need to be enforced in some way.
Yeah I just looked up what Shariah law is and people should be free to observe practices voluntarily as a religion, but religious law should not be permitted to override equal civil rights or be imposed coercively on people who do not consent to it.
In practice, however, parents are free to force on and brand their children with their religion
yes, the equal rights amendment didn't pass and so not everyone has equal rights
I agree. We should ban all laws written with a religious basis
Well... for starters
...
But more broadly, one does question why states that have already banned Sharia law in some capacity keep coming back to find new ways to ban religious organization
Increasingly, these prohibitions on "Sharia" begin to look like attempts by the state to harass Muslim religious communities and interrupt secular land development and business activity.
Y'all Qaeda is coming closer to Sharia Law than Islam ever will in the US.
Funny how the ones who can't shut up about the 2nd amendment seemingly forgot the 1st exists.
finally someone saying culture war is pointless because conservatives are using it to hurt minorities, instead of criticising left wingers for treating lgbt people's rights as important
What would conservatives/regressives do with their time if they weren't making themselves victims while actively violating the Constitution by persecuting those that they don't view as equal?
Won't you please think about conservative/regressive feelings? It's all they're thinking about.
I see no reason not to ban them all considering they are a net negative to the world.
upholding the constitution is more important than a few "human rights", same with banning Nazism