Have you noticed this phenomena on forums
Every time I search something like "Why is X bad?" on reddit or other forums, the majority of comments is always people arguing the exact opposite. This has been my experience countless times over the years. Recently I started searching the opposite of what I want to know, like "Why is X good?", and it works flawlessly.
That's essentially Cunningham's Law in action - "the best way to get the right answer on the internet is not to post a question - it's to post the wrong answer."
This plus a dose of a natural disdain for being given an answer in the question.
The proper way to phrase a question should be "what is your opinion on X?". Asking why X is good forces me to accept your assumption that it is good.
I see it on here too. Some people really feel strongly the opposite. Some people kind of just want to be dicks.
I think it depends on how you say it. In general, I think it's a good thing see other people's opinion, especially if you already have a certain bias. IMHO there are very few topics that have only arguments in one direction.
I've noticed the opposite actually, searching "why does X suck" gives me exactly the hate filled responses I was looking for to validate my rage lol
Have you noticed the phenomenon on fora where people decline Greek and Latin nouns incorrectly?
... did you just post "Why are 'Why is X bad?' posts bad?"