I think these are the result of a brigade attempt but I don't know any of those people and can't confirm.
Having said that, the Fediseer’s purpose is to provide a chain of trust system for the Fediverse. Its mission is to help instance administrators fight spam, bots, and malicious domains by making it easier to manage whitelists of trusted instances instead of endlessly chasing spam through blocklists.
My instance is small, has no bots, and no daily reports against users. I'd say these censures are arbitrary and personal in nature instead of violations of Fediseer's purpose
They won't be able to see this as they defed redlemmy. I think the explanations on fediseer speaking for themselves. This link dbzero provides is pretty damning: https://redlemmy.com/post/redlemmy.com/99913
(Fun fact, I'm actually instance banned from redlemmy, lol)
You may want to be clear when you ask the Lemmy developers what the "situation" is. Their Github is pretty active and I'm sure they'd appreciate some clarity in your request.
I'd phrase it simply: is my instance Redlemmy.com a bot or spam instance? If not, do censures against it on Fediseer warrant action?
Looking at it as an outsider and with no idea how the endorsement/censure system works, could that be five separate shitty messages from the instance admin; or is it one shitty message and four instances censuring in solidarity?
...but not necessarily based in meaningful or even true critique. The FAQ says "An censure is a completely subjective negative judgement from one instance to another. Effectively signifying that instance A "disapproves" of instance B. The reason for this can be anything and do not have to be stated."
Frankly I'm not sure why you cited this as a reply to my original comment, in which I was sharing my instance name for visibility. What was your purpose here?
Hi, I'm the instance owner being censured on the Fediseer.
The Fediseer is used to identify spam/bot instances.
Instance owner drama is fun and juicy, but doesn't qualify an instance as spam- or bot-related.
The Fediseer is being misused here by someone that I argued with, probably in a Leftist community. They're supposed to use it to protect users from spam, not to "downvote" people after a dispute. And to be clear, there are no bots, and no spam coming from my instance.
Hopefully @[email protected] can shed some light onto why she called this out, or what she hoped to accomplish by doing so
While your opinion is valid, I'd encourage you to verify with measurable data (ie. look at my instance) rather than make an uninformed decision. We're a small instance with a single owner, no bots or spam, and our political preferences are clearly visible on the sidebar :) best of luck to you !
27 replies
Holy shit. We're famous! What do I say, what do I do?
Hello. 👋
You deserve the surge in signups!
Which one is the last one?
what are the first two?
Reddthat and Lazysocial
That is scribe.disroot.org on Lemmy 0.19.12
Thank you!
I have a feeling its disroot
Yep, scribe.disroot.org
ok but you guys know about redlemmy right
lots of posts about dreams
adding new members daily
Update: Checking fediseer, it says your instance has 8 censures :(
I think these are the result of a brigade attempt but I don't know any of those people and can't confirm.
Having said that, the Fediseer’s purpose is to provide a chain of trust system for the Fediverse. Its mission is to help instance administrators fight spam, bots, and malicious domains by making it easier to manage whitelists of trusted instances instead of endlessly chasing spam through blocklists.
My instance is small, has no bots, and no daily reports against users. I'd say these censures are arbitrary and personal in nature instead of violations of Fediseer's purpose
@[email protected] @[email protected] @[email protected] @[email protected]
Any further comments on this situation?
They won't be able to see this as they defed redlemmy. I think the explanations on fediseer speaking for themselves. This link dbzero provides is pretty damning: https://redlemmy.com/post/redlemmy.com/99913
(Fun fact, I'm actually instance banned from redlemmy, lol)
The user in question has dug through my post history to condemn my words in replies. Oh deer… they got you too.
Yeah, it was for this post: https://feddit.uk/post/24213119
The the way they're going through your profile is defo what I'd consider harassment.
They definitely went too far with that ban.
I surprised they have the patient to go through my profile I’m not that interesting.
You may want to be clear when you ask the Lemmy developers what the "situation" is. Their Github is pretty active and I'm sure they'd appreciate some clarity in your request.
I'd phrase it simply: is my instance Redlemmy.com a bot or spam instance? If not, do censures against it on Fediseer warrant action?
Fediseer is an independent project that has nothing to do with the Lemmy developers.
It is also not only about bot spam.
Correct on all counts! Good job!
Looking at it as an outsider and with no idea how the endorsement/censure system works, could that be five separate shitty messages from the instance admin; or is it one shitty message and four instances censuring in solidarity?
There are 3 types of reviews admins can bestow upon an instance: endorsement, hesitation or censure.
All censures are from independent admins.
...but not necessarily based in meaningful or even true critique. The FAQ says "An censure is a completely subjective negative judgement from one instance to another. Effectively signifying that instance A "disapproves" of instance B. The reason for this can be anything and do not have to be stated."
Frankly I'm not sure why you cited this as a reply to my original comment, in which I was sharing my instance name for visibility. What was your purpose here?
Hi, I'm the instance owner being censured on the Fediseer.
The Fediseer is used to identify spam/bot instances.
Instance owner drama is fun and juicy, but doesn't qualify an instance as spam- or bot-related.
The Fediseer is being misused here by someone that I argued with, probably in a Leftist community. They're supposed to use it to protect users from spam, not to "downvote" people after a dispute. And to be clear, there are no bots, and no spam coming from my instance.
Hopefully @[email protected] can shed some light onto why she called this out, or what she hoped to accomplish by doing so
Oh that's a thing? "RedLemmy" is what I call ![email protected]. I can't look away from that train wreck.
oh, shit
I did not think the name through
it was supposed to sound similar to "reddit"
I wouldn't have assumed it was red as in politically right, my first assumption was reddit adjacent. I think you're fine 🤷♂️
While your opinion is valid, I'd encourage you to verify with measurable data (ie. look at my instance) rather than make an uninformed decision. We're a small instance with a single owner, no bots or spam, and our political preferences are clearly visible on the sidebar :) best of luck to you !