Spyke
feddit.de

I am always skeptical when new encryption protocols are announced. We already have quite a few properly reviewed and proven ones. Any new one has to stand all those tests first before it can be considered secure.

9
lemmy.ml

If it is based on Tor and Signal its not "new" and its probably a bad tech writer not understanding the details.

5

If a new protocol is based on Tor and Signal, it's still a new protocol. If they don't use the existing protocols unmodified, they might break crucial parts in the larger security model.

Edit: even the website states

Veilid is a new, distributed communication protocol developed by Cult of the Dead

4
SheeEttinreply
lemmy.world

It sounds like it's a new app using existing encryption.

2
aksdbreply
feddit.de

That doesn't say anything. I can tell you "I am using AES256" which is a proven cipher, but I can use it totally wrong, by using an inadequate block mode or not initializing it correctly. Or by using shitty keys, inadequate pseudo-random sources, etc.

2

And you can leak metadata left and right, while having the actual message encrypted.

4

This news makes it sound like theres no encrypted messaging protocols around. I wish it was more clear what is special about this one. Is it the integration of onion routing and end to end encryption into one protocol?

7

Sounds great, the more options users have the better, I say!

1

You reached the end

Cult of the Dead Cow Launches Encryption Protocol + ChatApp to preserve privacy. | Spyke