Anybody else think it was messed up that Data kept Spot trapped in his quarters?
I just re-watched TNG "In Theory" (S04E25) and Data says that the door to his quarters is set to only allow humanoids to enter or leave when Geordie finds Spot in the hall.
Whilst I get that it would be dangerous for Spot to wander the ship freely I think it's kind of mean to keep him locked in a small room like that forever. There doesn't seem to be any cat toys in the room but maybe the computer is capable of some sort of environmental enrichment we can't immediately see.
Do you have a cat? There would be several episodes about Spot breaking various ship systems and causing cat-astrophes
Your summary feels like an episode of Lower Decks demanding to be written!
T'Ana
What does T'Ana feel about humanoids having pet cats in the first place?
"Why does everyone have to tell ME about their f***ing pets?!"
Probably the same way we'd feel about someone having a capuchin monkey
cat-astro-phes
Damage on a Federation space ship would create a hefty ...
cat-astro-fee
I want cat-as-trophy
seems like data would just pin a communicator to his collar and beam him back if he got the urge to go walkabout.
Comm badge chirp
"Mowwww, Mowwww, mrrrowwww."
"Excuse me, I have an urgent matter to attend to."
I do and yea, he would have caused complete havoc on board the Enterprise.
Not really. His quarters seem spacious enough and as long as he has plenty of engagement - which we can assume he did because of his study of having a pet, indoor cats are perfectly happy lazy balls of frustrating love.
I mean, there are trucker cats who are happy.
Plus, cats are nocturnal and are most active at night. Data does not always sleep, so on nights where he’s not on the bridge, he could be spending quality time with Spot.
Cats are actually crepuscular, meaning they're most active at dawn and dusk, but they can be trained to keep to a mostly human sleep schedule (by which I mean sleeping 8 of their 15 daily hours at the same time you do).
Thanks for this. Cats being nocturnal never made much sense to me. They're definitely active a lot at night but its not like they just have an inverted sleep schedule from humans.
He does tell spot that that he is a good cat and a pretty cat.
Not to mention the fact that Data is literally incapable of getting bored.
Good point
Yeah, I get the impression TNG quarters are about the size of a studio apartment, which isn't amazing for cats, but it can work if you keep them entertained.
Yeah, lots of things are perfectly happy if they never get to expand their horizons.
That program? An almost completely empty holodeck, with a single cardboard box in a corner.
And a little light ball, like a reflection off a watch face, that sometimes appears that just randomly moves around and, importantly, can be “caught” (as in has a physical presence, sometimes).
In the holodeck you can catch the red dot.
Totally. I started thinking that as I was posting. Or you could have like a motorised laser pen. Thinking about it, you could easily hide something like that in the walls of the TNG style starship quarters.
Computer, set cat toy to stun
Geordi... I cannot stun my cat
Didn't Data play with spot at one point with a cat toy? One of those feather toys on the end of a string? I swear I remember this happening.
I have an introvert cat that would think I was torturing her if I were to make her leave her little spaces.
My cat was the opposite. He longed for adventure! Excitement! The great outdoors.
I'd take him on walks on a little cat harness. He was perfectly happy to roam. I think we got 4 blocks away one time before I finally had to say "Look, cat, it's getting late. Time to go home again."
He was a very good cat.
Meanwhile, Picard's lionfish in that tiny-ass globe:
blubApparently, his name is Livingston.
Dr Livingston I presume?
Yes, but the doctorate is honorary.
I always imagined that there was an unseen conduit for the lionfish to go hang out in the Cetacean ops ecosystem.
It seems like the upper staff on the ship get quarters that are roughly the size of a 1 or 2 bedroom apartment. Not great, but not worse than what lots of people do IRL.
Plus maybe he sometimes takes spot to a cargohold for more active play. There would be plenty of space, lots of height, etc. And that's all before even considering the holodeck.
So you have never lived in an apartment and had a cat?
Not at the same time.
Well, millions of people do, and the cats live happy, healthy lives.
I think it's more messed up that Spot changed breeds and genders more than ones.
Data kept killing Spots.
Plot twist:: it was always a hologram
Plot twist 2: it was a droid capable of changing it's fur
I'm sure Data had Spot out at one point and they spent six hours climbing through Jeffrey's Tubes to find him.
Jeffrey must have been sore afterward!
He was so mad he became an evil computer.
Now I'm wondering if Data ever brought Spot to the Holodeck. "Computer, run program Spot #7" (looks like a farm setting with space-squirrels and such)
Space squirrels that Spot can murder.
Like a cat version of Worf and Jadzia’s program
So you think that no one living in an apartment should own a cat?
All cats are different. But I don't think most of them would be happy in an apartment as small as Data's quarters.
To be fair, you can't treat Spot like an outdoor cat on a space ship. Unlike kids there's no one assigned to Spot to keep track of them in an emergency.
And before you say well Data is responsible for that, keep in mind data will pretty always have his attention monopolized by an emergency on this ship. So the best thing for Spot is to be in a known location.
Wait, didn't spot become pregnant with an unknown other ship cat? This would imply at least some kind of free roaming.
https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Spot
I checked a transcript, and saw this line between him an Barclay, implying not only that Spot "escaped," but that there are other cats also loose:
gonna find the father and get child support kibble lol
Huh. I always thought Spot was male. Probably because I've always had male cats myself.
He was male. But not in that episode.
And he's orange.
I used to have an orange female cat...
I have one sitting on me rn. They're uncommon, but exist
Are you kidding? Spot got out whenever she damn well felt like it. There's no way that Data didn't figure out how to keep the cat from unlocking the door; I'm pretty sure that spot came and went whenever she felt like it. Especially when you remember that all of the toughest guys on the ship were terrified of that cat lol
In the episode where Spot gives birth, it is clear Spot gets out.
I feel like TNG missed a trick by not have a Feline Ops department.
"Ensign Spot, what is your report on the feline habitability of Eridani 3?"
"Meh."
They used to be allowed to run through the decks but then they started peeing in the Jeffrey's tubes and engineers couldn't work with the smell.
Animals, not kids or personnel, should have the primary use of holodecks, if not just their own to live in.
Yeah, TNG has some horrible things that are just glanced over.
I've watched it recently and it held up worse than I thought it did (Voyager did better).
Maybe Spot gets holodeck time
Does the prohibition of genetic enhancement also apply to pets?