Spyke
fedia.io

To be fair, the Maginot line wasn't breached. The Germans went around it.

66
BakerBagelreply
midwest.social

Which was the entire point of the line. Belgium back out if their defense deal with France, and even German high command was pissed about how quickly Rommel was going through Northern France. Fall Gelb was absolutely balls to the wall insane and could have seen the German Panzers encircled if the Allied forces had been the least bit competent.

27
Anticorpreply
lemmy.world

if the Allied forces had been the least bit competent

This is honestly the first time that I've ever heard someone say that the Allied forces were incompetent. They did win the war after all.

-7
BakerBagelreply
midwest.social

Eventually, but it took a lot of trial and error to get that far. Very few Allied commanders who started the war managed to finish it.

36

100%. The British army, at the time, was good for little more than putting down colonial rebellions against vastly inferiors foes.

Tbf to them though, at the time, no one had any reason to expect hundreds of mobile artillery fortresses, driven by methed out nazis, to appear 50 miles behind them.

15
lemm.ee

I guess you could say the Allied forces won the war because their command structure was better at replacement than the Axis

1

It was more about resources. The allies were basically the rest of the world between the British, French, and Dutch empires. Japan did more to disrupt that than Germany did, and Germany was eventually knocked out of the Naval war, which left Britain free to import as much as they needed from those combined empires. And the Nazis were running out of fuel, which is why they invaded USSR.

WWII ended up being a war of attrition just like WWI was, the main difference was that Germany was able to take a lot more territory before their lack of resources caught up with them.

3

The Nazis were winning for most of the war. The UK might have been knocked out of the war entirely if the Nazis hadn't paused their advance and given them a chance to get their men back across the channel, which they needed to borrow civilian boats to do.

3
Technusreply
lemmy.zip

inb4 Russia steamrolls through Lithuania to get around the barrier

25
kbin.social

Completely useless and the fucking Muscovites will use human waves to breach the line. The best solution, a shit ton of tungsten pellets, cluster munitions, willy pete and my favorite...napalm. Bring back fucking napalm!

12
huginnreply
feddit.it

Completely useless and the fucking Muscovites will use human waves to breach the line.

I mean given the tactics in Ukraine it's not out of the question...

9
Piraspreply
lemmy.world

By the time they reach Poland there will be no meat left to throw at the line.

2

Why is that?

It's not like Belarus will resist them

2

Now imagine me in the Eastern Line

Sitting on a mine in the Eastern Line

Now it's turned out nice again

The Army life is fine

Putin can't kid us a lot

His secret weapon's genocide

But you ought to see what the polish got

Down on the Eastern Line

Down on the Eastern Line

6
EmoDuckreply
sh.itjust.works

Not pointless, a somewhat protected border is better than a not protected border if they have to go around it

That was the entire point of the Maginot line

4
Aqariusreply
lemmy.world

There's a philosophical question: if it did it's job flawlessly, and still accomplished nothing, is it pointless?

2
EmoDuckreply
sh.itjust.works

It accomplished slowing the Germans down and forcing them with going thought the rougher terrain of Belgium. That's far from nothing

8
Aqariusreply
lemmy.world

As I said, it worked flawlessly, but if it worked flawlessly, but France still got overrun, it'skinda debatable what the point was?

1

What's the point of seatbelts if people wearing them might still die in car crashes? Might as well get rid of them then

13

Except that the only way for these fucks to go around the Eastern Shield is to go through Ukraine, and that's not exactly possible for these idiots

1

You reached the end