How cinnamon, nutmeg and ginger became the scents of winter holidays, far from their tropical origins
https://theconversation.com/how-cinnamon-nutmeg-and-ginger-became-the-scents-of-winter-holidays-far-from-their-tropical-origins-218329Open linkView original on discuss.tchncs.de
But . . . They don’t answer the premise of the article?
Like, it’s interesting information about those plants but they don’t say why they’re associated to holiday season? Cinnamon harvested after monsoon season (uh, whenever that is, they assume we know but) and ginger can be harvested whenever - but when did those spices become part of the Northern Hemisphere’s holiday? When did it happen? Who started it? How did it start? They don’t say.
They...do?
I'm not the person you replied to but I think they still have a point. Your quote makes a mention of why ginger is used in winter since the middle ages, fair enough, but I highly doubt cinnamon and nutmeg were chosen consciously for their insulin interaction- first because it's a relatively mild effect, second because this knowledge is relatively new (did humanity know of insulin before using these spices during the holiday season?).
I think most people reading the headline expect to find some strong historical context on why, for example perhaps these spices became cheaper or more popular during some period for whatever reason.
Yes, the article could indeed provide more information on this. There was still a small attempt, let's say
Thanks for saving me a click.
My (unverified) but from a medieval museum I Denmark.
Spices where expensive - only for the richest. The holidays are important, so the expensive spices where used in holidays to celebrate properly.
That reminds me the ginger I was growing in my yard. Just as a curiosity. It spread wonderfully in the summer... and when winter came it said "nope, screw this tsundere climate." [Protip: if your homeland's weather is a rollercoaster, don't bother growing ginger.]
Funnily enough even in my chunk of the southern hemisphere those spices end a bit associated with winter, I believe. June and its mulled wine (or mulled rum for some - I find it distasteful, but you do you).
Eh, I think the Christmas spice combo is actually cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, and cloves.
Ummmm... actually 🤣
Stumbled upon this, didn't really know where to post it, seems in the theme for our community