More disqualifications due to plank wear possible in Brazil - Russell
https://www.racefans.net/2023/11/03/more-disqualifications-due-to-plank-wear-possible-in-brazil-sprint-round-russell/Open linkView original on lemmy.worldSyndicated from the fediverse. Read and engage on the original instance.
View original on lemmy.worldhttps://www.racefans.net/2023/11/03/more-disqualifications-due-to-plank-wear-possible-in-brazil-sprint-round-russell/Open linkView original on lemmy.world
22 replies
Planning to run low, are ya?
This feels like the ground work to force a relaxed application of the rules.
Merc will continue throwing a bitchfit unless and until this happens.
I wish it was the groundwork to get rid of sprint weekends
I find it odd that every car isn't checked after the race for things like this.
Every car is checked for weight and fuel, right? Why not check everyone for other easy to measure criteria?
It takes a lot of time to do these tests, and the risk of being chosen to be tested is usually enough deterrence to prevent teams from breaking the rules. They definitely should increase the number of cars they check for plank wear now though.
They also don't check the fuel of every car, only half of the cars.
I know some of the tests are hard to perform, and not practical to do on every car. But I can't imagine how some tests, especially plank checks, aren't feasible to perform on every car.
I think it mainly has to do with logistics. Some of the races are really close together (like US and Mexico) so the teams start packing the cars into crates immediately when the race ends so they can get to the next race on time. If every team had to have the plank check be done on their cars, some of the teams would have to wait a long time until the FIA officials finally get to their car, remove the plank from the bottom, and use take the measurements to check the legality.
A plank check is not just taking out a ruler and checking the width of the plank. https://youtu.be/ldD0lWG1fjQ?feature=shared explains more about why this is more complicated than people think and hence why it is not feasible for the FIA to check all the cars
Edit : could somebody check the piped link below to see of it works for them. I use piped but the formula 1 channel and all its videos never load for me.
The piped link doesn't work for me either.
Interesting video, but it doesn't really explain how the planks are measured though. Is the FIA using a micrometer? CMM? Laser?
I don't see why removing the planks for measurement is such a problem either. The teams will be removing and replacing the planks whether or not they get measured.
Can confirm the piped link isn't working for me either. If this is an ongoing issue we will need to review if the bot should be on the sub.
Also the problem with the planks is clearly an FIA problem. They could have an easier measurement method instead of making it so complex. They could simply mill wear lines into that plank that can be checked visually and if a visual check fails then do the more detailed one.
Here is an alternative Piped link(s):
https://piped.video/ldD0lWG1fjQ?feature=shared
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source; check me out at GitHub.
ha right when Oscar was sparking like crazy the announcers were talking about just that.
Let the boys race! For fucks sake. Rules suck when they DQ racers over technicalities.
Lol this isn't just a technicality. It's a major part of the sporting regulations.
Well test every car then. DQ everyone who fails.
That isn't even possible given the amount of time it would take. Lewis, is that you?
There are only 20 cars. How hard is it to measure 20 planks?
Would depend how long parc fermé lasts after the race, what equipment they're using to test, etc.
I’d like to see how many cars fail.
I'm not sure, but it's telling that Merc and Ferrari were the only teams who ran their cars so aggressively at the USGP. RB and McLaren actually raised their cars and planned for it, thus not failing the post-race inspection.
It takes about 30 minutes to check a plank. If it can be done in parallel then that's not too bad, if not 10 hours is too long.