I honestly don't think the voting does anything. It's all about what they feed you and how you move around the screen. And god help you if you click on one thing new but not sure if you'll like, because now it's ALL that niche. No likes or dislikes involved at all. Do I see more of the subscribed and liked things I have now? Nope. You'll see what YT wants you to see.
I shouldn't talk too bad though, as going to YT with a clean browser and no sign in gets all sorts of garbage, so at least I'm not seeing all of that. I don't know how though.
voting counts as activity driving engagement IIRC. I upload videos once in a blue moon and I personally care about that ratio, but I don't know about other creators (like ones who actually are partnered and earn).
I stopped using it recently when they had an update every other day and Firefox was requesting more permissions for me to accept.
I wasn’t sure why or what, so went to the comments to see. The way the dev was responding to people really put me off, though to their credit, they did go back and edit them to be more polite. It just threw me off though, so maybe everything is still fine but I probably won’t be using it again. :-/
They already did for me on Shorts, even with Return YouTube Dislike. I now have to utilize the "Not interested" and "Don't recommend channel" functions extensively.
Doesn't clicking the dislike button move the video up in the algo anyway? It's "engagement." If you don't like a video the best thing to do is "not interested" it on your recommendation page.
24 replies
How would they know? They removed the dislike button!
Dad?
Doesn't really matter, they already made it pointless.
You're not allowed to express anything negative, it's bad for the advertisers.
YouTube: Where a bigoted Christian can go on a transphobic tirade, but I'm the one who gets in trouble for telling them to fuck off.
didnt they already make it useless??
I've been slowly phasing out my YouTube consumption in favor of Nebula, Dropout, and sailing the seven seas
Yep. Nebula has most of the creators and content with none of the bullshit. Same for dropout.
I honestly don't think the voting does anything. It's all about what they feed you and how you move around the screen. And god help you if you click on one thing new but not sure if you'll like, because now it's ALL that niche. No likes or dislikes involved at all. Do I see more of the subscribed and liked things I have now? Nope. You'll see what YT wants you to see.
I shouldn't talk too bad though, as going to YT with a clean browser and no sign in gets all sorts of garbage, so at least I'm not seeing all of that. I don't know how though.
Wouldn't that be an argument for factoring it into recommendations, and not a reason to remove dislikes?
... OH WAIT, I made the mistake of thinking Google cares about providing a good user experience over pushing ads and an agenda, whoopsie!
the whole website is smelly dog ass excretions
Literally devolving into cable
Dating myself, but I remember when cable was the way to get quality entertainment without the network commercials.
And that was escaping broadcast TV, who still had like 45 minutes to a show with just 15 minutes for commercials spaced out mostly in the middle part.
And some of the commercials were actually pretty good.
voting counts as activity driving engagement IIRC. I upload videos once in a blue moon and I personally care about that ratio, but I don't know about other creators (like ones who actually are partnered and earn).
I still watch YouTube by subscribing to channels with RSS. I see what the people I follow upload. Nothing more, nothing less.
Cool extensions for people: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/return-youtube-dislikes/
I stopped using it recently when they had an update every other day and Firefox was requesting more permissions for me to accept.
I wasn’t sure why or what, so went to the comments to see. The way the dev was responding to people really put me off, though to their credit, they did go back and edit them to be more polite. It just threw me off though, so maybe everything is still fine but I probably won’t be using it again. :-/
Fair enough. If theres a better one, im all for it. Its not all that hard to implement honestly.
They already did for me on Shorts, even with Return YouTube Dislike. I now have to utilize the "Not interested" and "Don't recommend channel" functions extensively.
If I have to use YouTube, blocking shorts is a great feature.
No sad, only happy!
"stop being so negative" It's like they hired cheerleaders and now it's just bubble heads in corporate... oh, wait.
The like button disappeared for me a week or so ago, no idea what's going on there.
Doesn't clicking the dislike button move the video up in the algo anyway? It's "engagement." If you don't like a video the best thing to do is "not interested" it on your recommendation page.
I've heard this one before.