[meta] a review template?
Maybe we could establish a simple template for the reviews?
Something like x/5 ratings for a few criteria :
- Communities
- Culture
- Moderation
- Availability
- Performance
- Federation
This won't replace a written assessment of course, it's just an at-a-glance view.
I like the general idea of having a template. This might prevent low effort one short sentence reviews.
However the template shouldn't strictly enforced. A reviewer might don't cover some criteria because he or she don't know how to review them or might have different criteria in mind.
I think putting an N/A in any criteria should be valid. But I agree on the non enforcement in general.
Or they, or it, or fae, or xe, or She, or doll, or ae...
Instead of listing every personal pronoun, it's more efficient to just say "they"