25 Years Ago Today, Buffy Got Rid of a Controversial Character (And Their Return Would Eventually Be Great)
https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/feature/25-years-ago-today-buffy-got-rid-of-a-controversial-character-and-their-return-would-eventually-be-great/Open linkView original on leminal.space
Riley leaving was totally expected. Everyone was surprised he stuck around after season 4 ended. He was too good. That was the point, his relative normie-ness and puppydog love contrasted Buffy's insecurities and jaded nature. She could never have Riley. His role is that tragedy.