Spyke
lemmy.ml

Here's my breakdown with a comparison.

I was really impressed with Hartman at ND so they got a big bump. I thought they'd be good, but I didn't anticipate how good they'd look on offense with Hartman.

I don't know why I expected SoCal to be better on defense. The offense looks to be fine, but you really can't just count on outscoring every team every week. so they dropped a good bit.

I'll try to avoid poll inertia as we move into week one, so I'd expect my ballot to rapidly change week-to-week.

RkWeek 0Week 1Change
1GeorgiaGeorgia
2MichiganMichigan
3Ohio StateOhio State
4AlabamaAlabama
5Penn StatePenn State
6WashingtonWashington
7SoCalLSU1
8LSUOregon1
9OregonNotre Dame7
10TCUTCU
11UtahUtah
12TennesseeSoCal-5
13clemsonTennessee-1
14Florida Stateclemson-1
15TexasFlorida State-1
16Notre DameTexas-1
17Kansas StateKansas State
18TulaneTulane
19Oregon StateOregon State
20South CarolinaSouth Carolina
21DukeDuke
22Boise StateBoise State
23Mississippi StateMississippi State
24Texas TechTexas Tech
25North CarolinaNorth Carolina
5

I don’t know why I expected SoCal to be better on defense

I can't believe Alex Grinch keeps getting away with it. How many times does he have to teach us that his defenses are not to be trusted? Still, dropping 5 spots after a week 0 game is extreme, but I respect the willingness to ditch poll inertia.

2

I’m really trying to make my ballot an estimation of the final poll, rather than a weekly power ranking.

Poll inertia must die for this to be reality

5
lemmy.ml

I still think SoCal is going to be good. I think they’d beat Tennessee based on what I’ve seen.

We’ll see what both teams look like next week

4

Submitted! Since mine is a computer poll, there aren't enough data points to adjust after week 0 without it getting screwy, so I used my preseason poll (USC and Notre Dame I feel are in a good spot anyway). My write up for that poll is here, but I'll start posting write ups as comments in this weekly thread.

Mods is there an appetite to make the results reflected in the banner?

I'm open to updating the banner weekly. I think we may need to switch to just showing the top 10 rather than 25. Anyone have thoughts on that?

3

Whatever makes it look nice I think. On one hand 10 is how the other website did it and maybe it'd be nice to be different. But on the other 10 is almost certainly easier and more aesthetic.

Edit: and any poll that ranks alabama lowly is a poll I can get behind

2

I submitted my poll, will be interested to see how results change after the first real week.

Mods is there an appetite to make the results reflected in the banner?

If this is something you want to do, I’m cool with it. I made you a mod so if you or @ToasterOverlord have a graphic you want to use for the banner after your poll feel free to change it.

Side note: I almost have all FBS team icons saved to my computer (and resized to make icons) so when I have the time to finish I’m going to revamp the sidebar a little. If you guys have ideas for this let me know, but we are limited to a 10,000 character count including formatting characters.

3

You reached the end

Week 1 c/cfb poll | Spyke